being, it has got feelings cause it bled by the time it was cut... it didn’t go
out to retaliate because it’s a tree... Now as human beings we have got
feelings and we have got motives...But if we re-align our brains as human
beings, ah, let us behave like trees so that we can then be able to reconcile
with ourselves.
This deduction made about the tree being nonviolent by nature was intriguing. It might have
had to do with the fact that the issue of revenge had featured prominently in our dialogues
and was an issue with which several of the participants struggled. The tree’s apparent
inability to react could have also been interpreted negatively under different circumstances.
The fact that the group interpreted this positively could be an indication of the effectiveness
of the process and the atmosphere under which the workshop was held. While acknowledging
the power of their emotions and motives for revenge, they also realized that as human beings
they were superior to the tree in the order of creation and, as such, they had a moral
obligation to resist reacting violently towards those perceived to be the perpetrators.
Facing the Everyday Realities
Further to the tenets discussed above, a few more lessons were drawn from the tree.
The first one, which is related to the above-mentioned tree’s ability to adapt, was that the tree
lived positively with its everyday realities. That is to say, the tree was not in denial about the
realities of its situation. “V” put it this way:
We have a saying that, when the tree is cut, the axe will forget but the tree won’t. It’s
another lesson, that tree will always have that stump and so even us as people we live
with the reality of our stumps, our branches are broken.
This was in reaction to the question posed about whether the participants were finding what
they had learnt at the workshop helpful in their everyday situations. They agreed that there
was a positive transformation but also acknowledged that they faced real obstacles as they
tried to apply lessons learnt. “M” stated it this way:
Let me say that it’s relief, because it is a short term relief, because, yes at that
time you will be relieved, but then you come back to the real society now; you
come back and as soon as you arrive you realize that you are still part of the
system... in the same environment which cut you down.
After having listened to the debate, my contribution to this point was as follows:
...When we were there it was almost like a mini paradise. Problems here are
not problems there, we are all in solidarity you know, we are crying with