12
Figure 2.
Comparison of the presence of militia: Electoral Irregularity Ratings
and Violence Score
14
12
Score
10
8
Electoral Irregularity Rating
Violence Score
6
4
2
0
no militia base
militia base
Presence of militia
As is additionally seen from Figure 3 [see over], the same effect is found when we examined the
detailed relationship between the presence of militia and the types of violence reported in the
constituencies sampled. Here we were interested to see beneath a global construct, such as a
Violence Score or an Electoral Irregularity Score, that physical violence, gender-based political
violence, and various forms of political party violence are all much more frequently reported in
constituencies where militia are also reported.
However, the presence of militia may not only be associated with violence in the conventional
sense. In a country in which physical violence has been extremely common according to all
reputable sources – both local Zimbabwean and international sources – and where all reports
have strongly implicated the youth militia in particular, it is evident that the presence of militia
may have other inhibitory effects. Hence, we examined the relationship between the presence of
militia and the interference with basic freedoms.
As is seen in Table 15 [see over], the presence of reported militia seems to markedly elevate the
percentage of constituencies reporting interference with some basic freedoms, but has had little
effect on others.
National Constitutional Assembly: Election Climate Reports.