m a ppi n g wo m en ’s n eeDs i n Zi m ba bw e’s nat i o na l h e a l i n g pr o ce ss
and every day, I am troubled because, until the police declare that they are dead,
we cannot register their deaths. This makes it difficult for me to use some of my
husband’s property because the authorities do not believe that they are dead since
they were linked with the opposition political party MDC-T. (Interview, 21 May 2011)
An analysis of these women’s narratives shows some resemblances with what Pauline Boss
(2006) refers to as the ‘ambiguity of loss’ in those who experience the traumatic loss or
disappearance of loved ones. The significance of seeing the dead body also brings closure
to the haunting experiences of denial, and allows relatives to grieve and conduct the
mandatory traditional rituals celebrating the life of the departed. Religious attitudes and
ritual obligations after death shape perceptions of the importance of human remains to
families. During interviews, most women concurred on the need to either see the human
remains or have absolute evidence of death in order to complete the necessary rituals. For
most women, particularly those in rural areas, documents alone cannot confirm the death of
someone who has disappeared – a sense of closure comes only with the retrieval of the body
or human remains. The issue of disappearances was also seen as an economic issue, with
relatives spending a lot of money consulting traditional healers in search of missing relatives.
For women who depended on their missing husbands financially, the loss of a breadwinner
often creates economic insecurity and poverty for those left behind.
Women activists indicated that, because of the continuing polarisation among members
of different political parties in Zimbabwe, families of the disappeared do not trust the
government’s investigative efforts, and this extends to a lack of confidence in cases where
remains are returned to them without DNA tests being carried out. As one woman remarked:
In our African culture, people do not just disappear or die. There is an explanation to
every death. Therefore, to perform burial rituals we need something like his clothes,
his bones or anything like that, but with what we are seeing now I don’t think this
is possible. Whoever is responsible has to tell us the whole story how they killed our
person, where they buried him and only then will the elders in the family accept to
perform the ritual. (Interview, 21 May 2011)
Analysis shows that the process of understanding death or disappearance due to politically
motivated violence is heavily embedded in cultural practice, which can be distinguished
from seeking the judicial truth. This implies that national healing in Zimbabwe needs to
take cognisance of cultural sensitivities in order to help promote healing and avoid further
emotional damage to those affected.
From a gender perspective, the disappearance or death of a male relative by political
abduction can also bring about an identity crisis among the women in his family. In
Zimbabwe, the traditional family is patri-local, in the sense that married women move to
the husband’s home on marriage. While this can provide economic and emotional support,
it can also become a great source of stress if the wives of the disappeared are alienated from
their husband’s family because of intergenerational and gender-related power relations.
Younger married women tend to find themselves at the bottom of family hierarchies in which
they are expected to be subservient to their mothers-in-law who are, in turn, dominated by
older men (Osirim, 2001).
Both urban and rural women talked of the stigma attached to a married woman whose
husband disappears due to politically motivated violence. If that woman decides to leave
her in-laws’ home or remarry, she can be seen as betraying both her husband and her inlaws. In many traditional cultures in Zimbabwe, as long as ambiguity remains about her
husband’s fate a married woman may not consider remarriage. Thus a married woman may
be trapped in a family that resents her presence, but does not want her to leave due to the
17
IJR Zimbabwe Womens needs OP proof 2.indd 17
7/16/2012 11:01:31 AM
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents