most of key perpetrators from the colonial era are too old, dead or are no longer residing in the
country.
Much more importantly, focus on individual responsibility exposes the limitations of
international law, which attends to physical rights violations and not the far-reaching effects of
colonialism in post-colonial societies. There is a common proclivity in Western legal renditions to
offer a universalistic positivist approach to international legal issues. Yet, in addition to the failure
to account for violations of bodily integrity rights, there are a number of indirect ways in which
colonialism fostered the culture of impunity in former colonies.
Opportunities – Previous Attempts at Truth Recovery
There have been state led attempts at truth recovery, initiatives by domestic and international
organisations and unofficial recording of history in vernacular novels.
State–led truth seeking initiatives
As discussed above, at independence the Mugabe regime adopted a policy of reconciliation and
subsequently granted amnesties to human rights abusers in all key historic periods. Heroes and
Independence Day celebrations commemorate the colonial legacy. Much more specifically, in
response to allegations of post–independence human rights abuses and demands for the truth,
the government established Commissions of Inquiries. For example, when faced with allegations
of human rights atrocities in military camps in 1981, the government reacted by setting up a
judicial commission of inquiry. Justice Enoch Dumbutshena chaired this body, which
investigated the events but was precluded from publicising its findings. In 1983, another
commission, chaired by Simplicius Chihambakwe was established to look into reports of killings
of civilians by the army in Matabeleland. Again the report was not published. Thus there is no
official truth; fact-finding has been largely confined to efforts of non-governmental
organisations and academics.
Civil society led initiatives
Nevertheless, in addition to state led initiatives, the country's opposition parties and civic society
have made parallel efforts. They have documented allegations of political violence, pursued civil
claims against the state and examined possible justice options. Civil society has also attempted
domestic and international litigation on behalf of post-independence human rights victims.
30
The Second International Conference on Transitional Justice in Zimbabwe
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents