and one which allowed Parliament to appoint a new president pending elections if the
incumbent (i.e. Mugabe) left office for any reason. Mbeki assured the MDC that the quid
quo pro would be an easing of repressive laws affecting elections. When Mugabe never
delivered on this undertaking, Mbeki did nothing.
Having won a two thirds majority in parliament in 2005, both Mbeki and Mugabe
believed that Mugabe could secure a victory in the March 2008 elections without
engaging in the violence which had characterized the 2000 and 2002 elections or fully
utilising the unrepealed and repressive laws which ought to have been amended as part of
the quid quo pro. Both were mistaken. Although the March 2008 “harmonized” elections
(where the Presidential, Senate, House of Assembly and Local Government elections
were held simultaneously) were a long way from fair (due the ZANU PF’s manipulation
of the voters’ roll, control over the electronic and printed media and use of state
resources, particularly food handouts, for party political purposes), they were certainly
the most free elections since the crisis began. The combined MDCs took 109 of 210
House of Assembly seats against ZANU PF’s 97. The elected seats in the Senate split
50:50. Although the results of all elections were known within 48 hours of the poll, the
Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC), eked out the results and announced them as if
dealing a pack of cards, with one seat declared won by the MDC, the next by ZANU PF.
The results of the presidential election, however, were withheld. The obvious reason was
that Mugabe had lost the poll. The Zambian president, as then chair of SADC, convened
an emergency summit to discuss the refusal of ZEC to declare the presidential result.
Mbeki swung into action to rescue Mugabe from his defeat. He travelled to Zimbabwe on
the way to the emergency summit, meeting Mugabe with the usual hugging and hand
holding. After a short meeting with Mugabe, Mbeki addressed reporters on the failure to
release the results of the presidential poll, stating that the delay was part of the “normal
electoral process in terms of the law of Zimbabwe”, when it clearly was not, and
infamously stated that he would not describe the situation “as a crisis”.
Mugabe decided that it would be politic not to attend the emergency SADC meeting.
However, his input was reportedly delivered by Mbeki, apparently causing Zambia
president Levy Mwanawasa to remark that “If Robert Mugabe has anything to say to me
as chairperson, then he can talk to me himself.” He added that Mbeki was creating the
impression that he was becoming “Mugabe's messenger”. In addition, Mbeki sought to
prevent Tsvangirai from addressing the SADC meeting, but was overruled by
Mwanawasa.
When the results of the presidential poll were finally released in May, the poll gave 1 195
562 votes (47.9%) to Morgan Tsvangirai, 1 079 730 votes (43.2%) to Robert Mugabe,
207 470 votes (8.3%) to Simba Makoni and 14 503 votes (0.6%) to Langton Towungana.
The lengthy delay in releasing the results lent credence to the notion that the results had
been manipulated to reduce Tsvangirai’s poll to below the 50% plus one necessary to
prevent a run off. The run off itself, which should have been held “within 21 days of the
previous election”, was delayed by ZEC to 27th June, 2008. Mugabe used the hiatus to