The Zimbabwean Experience of Transitional Justice
Although the history of the Liberation War has been written about
copiously, and there has been a largely unsuccessful attempt through the War
Victims Compensation Act [Chapter 11 : 16] to offer redress to the victims, the
human rights history remains largely unexplored. The human rights violations
committed by the Rhodesian forces are known, but not so those of the liberation
forces. Furthermore, the attempt to compensate the thousands of victims has
been derailed completely by the scandal involving the fraudulent disbursement
of the funds. Impunity, too, has left its mark on the social and political processes
of Zimbabwe.
Thus, it is clear that ZANU(PF) can take enormous credit for the liberation
of Zimbabwe from a traitorous and brutal regime, but, unlike the ANC, it has
never admitted its own violations, except in passing. There still remain issues to
be explained: the Nhari rebellion, the assassination of Herbert Chitepo, and the
whole dissolution of ZIPRA remain shrouded in mystery – and, of course, the
various impunities render this history even more opaque.
The story of the 1980s
What happened to you in 1980s? This is also a question that has been asked. Not
much for a very long time, but the story has now been told in earnest.11
You would pretty well have to speak Ndebele if you had had a bad experience
in the 1980s, during the so-called Gukurahundi. The violence and torture were
confined largely to the southern half of Zimbabwe, and seemed to be specifically
targeted at Ndebele-speaking people, who were assumed to be supporting the
‘dissidents’. The methods used to punish the recalcitrant during the Liberation
War returned in a new and devastating form: pungwes, ‘thorough beatings’
and torture, and public executions – all were used, predominantly by the Fifth
Brigade, a special force reporting to the President and ZANU(PF). The difference
from the Liberation War was that no one was spared the terror. Whether you
were a member of PF-ZAPU, a former member of ZIPRA, or merely an ordinary
resident of Matabeleland North or South, you could be a victim. This was not a
11
See Catholic Commission for Justice and Peace in Zimbabwe and Legal Resources Foundation,
Breaking the Silence, Building True Peace: Report on the Disturbances in Matabeleland and the
Midlands, 1980 to 1989 (Harare: CCJPZ and LRF, 1997); Zimbabwe Human Rights Association,
Choosing the Path to Peace and Development: Coming to Terms with Human Rights Violations
of the 1982–1987 Conflict in Matabeleland and Midlands Provinces (Harare: ZimRights, 1999).
A summary of Breaking the Silence is available at: <http://www.kubatana.net/docs/hr/ccjp_
lrf_breaking_silence_9904.pdf>. Accessed 29 Jan. 2013.
International Conference on Transitional Justice, Zimbabwe
35
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents