Anthony Reeler
outside military or police control – the Fifth Brigade, the CIO and ZANU(PF)
Youth – were the major perpetrators, the Fifth Brigade being the overwhelming
culprit. This speaks right to the crux of the problem: that ZANU(PF) remained a
liberation movement at heart and had not made the transformation to a civilian,
democratic party. This becomes a factor in understanding the problems of the
new millennium.
The story of the 1990s
The story of the 1990s is somewhat different from that of the previous two
decades. There were relatively few victims of politically inspired organized
violence and torture during most of the decade. Moreover, civil society had an
increasing ability to monitor and document the misbehaviour of the state, and
this was described in a number of reports.15
As a victim, you would be most likely to have suffered at the hands of the
police as a suspect in a criminal investigation, although you might have run foul
of political party supporters during the general election in 1995. There was at
least one celebrated assassination attempt, on Patrick Kombayi, which followed
the usual pattern: found guilty of attempted murder, Kombayi’s assailants were
immediately pardoned by the President, Robert Mugabe. However, the number
of victims reported in the 1990s were relatively few, as seen in the reports of
Zimbabwean human rights organizations such as the CCJPZ and ZimRights,
as well as in the reports of international bodies such as Amnesty International.
As a citizen, you could be forgiven for believing that the nation was making the
all-important transition from a liberation-war ideology to modern democratic
principles. You would have changed your mind by the end of the decade.
However, if you were a student, you would have few illusions about the police
and especially the riot police. At demonstration after demonstration, you would
have witnessed unrestrained violence, with beatings, tear gas, dogs and the lot
being unleashed upon the university campus. On every occasion that the riot police
met the students, it was clear that the principle of ‘minimum force’ had a different
meaning for the Zimbabwe Republic Police riot squad from that conventionally
accepted. That the student body increasingly rejected ZANU(PF) may have had
15
See A Consolidated Report on the Food Riots, 19–23 January 1998, comp. Amani Trust
on behalf of the Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum (Harare: The Forum, [1999]), available
at
<http://hrforumzim.org/wp-content/uploads/1998/01/consolidatedreportonfood.pdf>,
accessed 8 Apr. 2013; see also Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum, Organised Violence and
Torture in Zimbabwe in 2000 (Harare: The Forum 2000).
38
International Conference on Transitional Justice, Zimbabwe
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents