Fwexcs (No. 2)
No.9
2&rs
(3) Information concerning a comparable uncontrollecl transaction
may not be relied upon by the taxpayer for the purposes of demonstrating
the consistency a transaction with section 9BB if the information on the
transaction is not available to the Commissioner.
{4) In the absence of information on uncontrolled transactions
from the same geographic market as the controlled trans action , cofitparable
uncontrolled transactions from othergeographic markets may be accepted
by the Commissioner.
(5 ) A
determi n ati on of wh ether c omparable s frorn other geograph ic
markets are reliable has to be made on a case-by-case basis, ancl by
reference to the extent to rvhich they satisfy paragraph 3 of this Schedule.
(6) Taxpayers using such comparables would be expected to
assess the expected innpact
of geographic differences and other factors
on the price and profitability.
Services between ossociated enterpt'ises
8. ( I ) A service charge between a taxpayer and an associated person
shall be considered consistent with the arm's length principle rvhere-
(a)
(b)
it is charged for
a service that is actually rendered; and
the service provides, or lvhen rendered was expected to
provide, the recipient rvith economic or comrnercial value
to enhance its cornmercial position; and
(c) it is charged for a service that an independent
enteqprise
in comparable circumstances would have been willing to
pay for if performecl for it by an independent enterprise, or
r,vould have performed in-house for itself; and
(d)
its amount corresponds to that which would have been agreed
between independent enterprises for cornparable services
in comparable circumstances.
(2) A service charge made to a person shall not be consistent
with the arm's length principle where it is made by an associated person
solely because of the shareholder's ownership interest in one or more
other group members, including for any of the following costs incurred
or activities undertaken by such associated person
(a)
-
costs or activities relating to the juridical structure of the
parent compan)'
of the {irst-mentioned
person, strch
as
meetings of shareholclers of the parent, issuing of shares
in the parent company and costs of the parent company's
supervisory board; and
(b)
costs or activities relating to reporting requirernents of the
parent company of the first-mentioned person, including
the consolidation of reports; and
(c)
costs or activities related to raising funds for the acquisition
of participations, unless those participations are directly
or indirectly acquired hy the first-mentioned person and
the acquisition benefits or is expected to benefit that firstmentionecl person.
r88