I would say we were not handled as if we were human beings when I was taken to the
police station. I was just handled terribly… I was held like a criminal. Everything was
harsh… I used to cry when I was in the cell. Cry for myself. In the evening.. All those I
remember very well, I can say ¾ of the days I was in the remand holding cells I wasn’t
sleeping. I didn’t have time to sleep. It was just terrible those days… That was my first
time to be held, in such a way, in a such situation. So it made it tough, cause when I
start to remember that I was in for nothing. I was in for no reason at all. I was just
makes me go wild, I just.. I just don’t feel like I’m a person with my rights. I was
deprived of my rights. I was assaulted. I was hassled. I was assaulted badly at that time
when I think of those days. I ..I just feel I wasn’t born. I just feel as if I wasn’t existing in
this place.
(Survivor from Mabvuku)
1. Introduction
As the Minister of Home Affairs himself commented in his address to the House of Parliament
on 3 February 1998, “...the just ended three day food riots which came soon after the
announcement of the general increase of prices of basic commodities, mealie meal, rice,
cooking oil and bread represent the most violent riots the country has experienced since
independence”. Indeed the whole nation was shocked by the Food Riots; not just by the rioting
of ordinary citizens, but also by the violence of the State’s response. Eight deaths, uncounted
injuries, thousands of people being arrested and detained made an enduring impression on the
nation.
The human rights community of Zimbabwe made strong appeals to Government to control the
situation and to obey the principle of “minimum force” that needs to be observed when dealing
with civilians. Amnesty International made a strong appeal to the Minister of Home Affairs to
repudiate his view that the situation required the use of arms of war and the shooting of
unarmed civilians.
The human rights NGOs in Harare swung into action following the many reports of human rights
violations, and the Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum (Human Rights Forum) was formed.
This group, a loose alliance of NGOs, provided assistance to detainees, persons complaining of
human rights violations and ill-treatment, and produced a report on the riots — Human Rights
in Troubled Times: An Initial Report on Human Rights Abuses During and After Food
Riots in January 1998 — which was forwarded to the President and Parliament in support of
the request for an independent commission of inquiry. As was stated in the report:
The human rights organisations call upon Government to set up, as soon as possible,
an independent Commission of Inquiry headed by a High Court Judge to investigate
these allegations of human rights violations. In the interests of transparency and
accountability the findings of this Commission must be made public. Pending the
setting up of such a Commission, the organisations request Parliament to establish its
own Committee to look into these allegations and report its findings to Parliament. In
conducting these investigations the Parliamentary Committee should enlist the
assistance of the Ombudsman’s office which now has jurisdiction to investigate
allegations of human rights abuses on the part of members of the police, army and
prison service. Although the Ombudsman may only investigate when complaints have
been made to that office, the proposed Parliamentary Committee would be able to refer
some of the complainants to the Ombudsman’s office so that their complaints can be
investigated by personnel in this office.
Following these inquiries arrangements must be made for compensation to be awarded
to all persons found to have suffered human rights abuses without those persons
having to bring claims in the courts. Government must also take stern disciplinary
action against all those who are proven to have perpetrated human rights abuses to
send a clear signal that this sort of misconduct will not be tolerated.