Witnessing assaults
1.2
Witnessing executions
0
WITNESSING TORTURE
1.2
The group did not report frequencies of torture as high as previous groups (AMANI.1998), which
again is unsurprising since most had only one encounter with the Police or the Army. Impact
Torture was reported much more frequently than other forms, and, of the forms of Impact
Torture, beatings were the most frequently reported.
Psychological abuse was reported with the greatest frequency. One important factor in the
pattern of abuse is that most of this group were tortured outside of detention.
Table 14
Unconsciousness reported by Food Riots victims
[n=42]
>30
minutes
7
30-60
minutes
1
60-120
minutes
1
<120
minutes
1
A very high proportion (24%) of the group reported unconsciousness, but most of these reported
unconsciousness of less than 30 minutes. For the majority of those reporting unconsciousness,
this was associated with gunshot wounds, but two members reported unconsciousness
following assaults. Unconsciousness is important to identify, both because of its association with
long-term disability and its status as an indicator of the severity of the assault.
Table 15
Symptoms reported by Food Riots victims on the Present Health Status
Questionnaire(PHSQ)
[n=42]
PHSQ(t
ot)
13.7
6.9
PHSQ(ps
y)
5.8
4.2
PHSQ(phy
s)
6.7
3.6
PHSQ(slee
p)
2.3
2.3
The group as a whole reported very high numbers of symptoms after the alleged torture. The
mean number of symptoms reported was 13.7[s.dev 6.9], and this was a mixture of both
psychological and physical symptoms. People with ordinary psychological disorders have been
shown to present with high numbers of symptoms — about 3 according to most Zimbabwean
studies — and this group has a considerably higher number of symptoms. This is probably due
to the combination of physical and psychological injuries.
The scores obtained from the Self-Reporting Questionnaire (SRQ-8) and the Harvard Trauma
Scale (HTS) additionally show that this group has experienced psychological problems as a
consequence of their alleged torture. The SRQ-8 is a psychiatric screening instrument, and all
scores in excess of 4/8 are strongly indicative of clinically significant psychological disorder.
Fifteen (36%) members of the sample reported scores in excess of 4/8, which is lower than
other Zimbabwean samples, but is undoubtedly due to the fact that most people experienced
only a single experience.
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents