lawyers who can trace them following their arrest and detention.123 Lawyers report
that such harassment is mainly at the hands of police in the Law and Order unit of
the Criminal Investigations Division, which has frequently been accused of abusing
the rights of detainees and their lawyers in political cases.124 Previously, the African
Commission had criticized the same Law and Order Section for serious human rights
abuses.125
According to the Law Society of Zimbabwe, police are frequently uncooperative and
hostile to lawyers, and many have long since ceased to respect the country’s legal
profession.126 In May 2007 police arrested lawyers Andrew Makoni and Alec
Muchadehama on spurious charges of “attempting to defeat course of justice
through a falsehood during the course of a bail application.”127 The two often
represent the MDC and others in political cases.
A human rights lawyer told Human Rights Watch how, on June 10, 2008, he was
made to search for clients accused of political violence at more than 13 police
stations in Harare simply because arresting police officers at the Law and Order unit,
Harare Central Police Station refused to give accurate details of where his clients
were being held.128 Eventually, after more than 10 hours of searching, driving from
one police station to another, he located the clients at Avondale Police Station,
where, at the beginning of the search he had been told emphatically that his clients
were not there. His clients told him that they were held at that particular police
station for the whole day.129
Police arrested MDC Secretary General Tendai Biti at Harare airport on June 12, 2008,
on his return from South Africa and immediately whisked him away. His lawyers
spent several days trying to locate where the police were holding him. After receiving
123
Human Rights Watch interviews with lawyers taking up political cases, Harare, August 21, 22, and 23, 2008.
124
Human Rights Watch interviews with lawyers, Marondera, August 27, 2008.
125
The African Commission Mission Report, Executive Summary of African Commission’s Fact-Finding Mission to Zimbabwe 24
to 28th June 2002, (2002).
126
Arnold Tsunga and Otto Saki, Persecution of Lawyers in Zimbabwe, Law Society of Zimbabwe, 2007.
127
Human Rights Watch interview with Lawyer, Alec Muchadehama, Harare, August 18, 2008.
128
Human Rights Watch interview with lawyer, Harare, August 29, 2008.
129
Ibid.
“Our Hands Are Tied”
36
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents