This report is based on research conducted by Human Rights Watch in Zimbabwe’s Harare,
Bulawayo, the Midlands, Manicaland, Mashonaland East, Central and West provinces in
November and December 2012, and in February 2013. The report illustrates how the
partisanship of the security forces’ leadership has translated into abuses by these forces
against the MDC and civil society organizations across the country and in political
interference. Human Rights Watch interviewed over 50 victims of abuses, legislators,
journalists, members of the army and police, lawyers, and rights activists. We also
reviewed Zimbabwe’s Lancaster House constitution and new constitution, various laws
and regulations, police reports, newspaper accounts and reports by local human rights
organizations.
There is an urgent need, ahead of the elections, for Zimbabwe’s security forces to be
drastically reformed, to create a political environment conducive for holding non-violent
and credible elections. Should the security forces fail to adopt a professional, independent
and non-partisan role during elections, the new constitution and other recent reforms
including the setting up of a new Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) and the licensing
of private daily papers, may be insufficient to deliver the elections needed to put
Zimbabwe on a democratic and rights-respecting track.
Institutional reforms have not been introduced by the power-sharing unity government
consisting of ZANU-PF, President Mugabe’s party, and the two factions of his Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC). Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai heads the larger of MDC’s
two factions. The unity government was established under the 2008 Global Political
Agreement (GPA), which was underwritten by SADC and the African Union (AU). It was
intended to make institutional and legal reforms to create a conducive environment for the
holding of free and fair elections. However, the outcome of the GPA was a ZANU-PF
dominated government with significantly more power than MDC’s two factions. ZANU-PF
has used its dominance to frustrate or block reform efforts.
Zimbabwe’s security forces, notably the military, have, for several years, interfered in the
nation’s political and electoral affairs in ways that have adversely affected the ability of
Zimbabwean citizens to vote freely. This was particularly evident during the 2008 elections
where the army played a major role in supporting widespread and systematic abuses that
led to the killing of up to 200 people, the beating and torture of 5,000 more, and the
displacement of about 36,000 people. Since then the leadership of the military, police and
THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM
2