is greatly reduced. Deportations are an ineffective and an expensive policy as
those deported almost always return within days.
8) The jailing and sentencing of immigrants for up to 4 years imprisonment who
breach immigration laws, which is soon to be implimented as it is included in the
Immigration Amendment Bill, is not practical as the department of correctional
services is already struggling with limited jail space. The situation is so bad in
prisons that a presidential pardon of prisoners with 6 months or less left on their
sentences was announced recently. The decision was attributed to overcrowding
in prisons, showing how desperate is the situation of overcrowding in South
African prisons.
9) The involvement of youth in immigration raids in Musina is a serious concern. The
encouraging of youths to combat crime is very dangerous as it can lead to
vigilantism and mob justice. Officials encouraging youth action, while often blaming
foreigners for crime, can lead to xenophobic violence.
10) The deportation of Zimbabweans in Musina without any due process- merely
herding immigrants into deportation trucks- needs to be halted immediately.
11) Corruption is very difficult to combat, without transparency and accountability.
Ensuring that procedures are consistently followed and immigrants were
adequately informed of their rights, would reduce the “opportunity” for corruption.
12) Better training on Immigration Law for SAPS and the removal of SANDF from
immigration control is necessary in order to demilitarise immigration raids.
13) An amalgamation of NGO’s working with refugees and migrants should consider
establishing an information system and a website on which instances of breaches
in law, harassment and corruption could be recorded.
8