An in-depth Study on the impacts of Operation Murambatsvina
Mutare and Bulawayo respectively. The general trend observed above, of trauma due to
Operation Murambatsvina, remains the same across the three sites: lack of food or water being the
most frequent across all three sites.
Table 6: Frequency of responses on Trauma Questionnaire [Percentages and ranks]
Harare
Bulawayo
Mutare
[n=570]
[n=386]
[n=239]
Lack of food or water
73.3% [1]
79.5% [1]
79.5% [1]
Ill health without access to medical care
47.4% [2]
43.9% [6]
51.2% [5]
Lack of shelter
51.9% [4]
32.2% [6]
48.5% [5]
Imprisonment
23.7% [14] 15.8% [14]
16.7% [16]
Serious injury
13.4% [17]
25.1% [13] 18.7% [10]
Caught up in combat
36.8% [7]
30.4% [11] 16.6% [13]
Rape
8.4% [22]
4.9% [22]
5.2% [23]
Forced isolation from others
18.8% [13]
30.5% [10] 13.9% [15]
Being close to death
27.2% [12]
31.9% [7]
17.9% [14]
Forced separation from family members
33.5% [8]
18.7% [10]
36.4% [8]
Murder of family or friends
8.8% [21]
6.7% [20]
8.8% [21]
Unnatural death of family or friends
22.9% [15]
8.3% [18]
13.4% [17]
Murder of stranger or strangers
3.7% [23] 1.04% [23]
9.6% [20]
Lost or kidnapped
11.2%
[20]
6.7% [20]
8.4% [22]
Severe beatings
32.1% [9]
32.9% [5]
34.3% [9]
Torture
22.5% [16]
30.3% [8]
20.1% [12]
Motor traffic accident
17.2% [17] 13.9% [15]
22.6% [11]
Industrial accident
16.5% [18]
7.5% [19]
12.1% [19]
Natural disaster(flood, fire, etc)
39.7% [7]
17.9% [12]
59.8% [2]
Any other situation that was very frightening
or you felt that your life was in danger
55.4% [2]
33.4% [4]
59% [3]
Confiscation or destruction of property
53.9% [3]
40.9% [3]
48.9% [4]
Sexual abuse other than rape
15.9% [19]
9.9% [17]
17.9% [14]
Feeling dependent on others
43.2% [6]
28.8% [9]
33.1% [10]
*xl
4.1.4
Trauma types over the years:
As was seen above, when we classified items on the trauma scale into hypothetical classes Operation Murambatsvina [OM] and Organized Violence and Torture [OVT] - we found strong
correlations between these classes and psychological disorder, as measured by the SRQ-8.
We also found strong agreement between the sites over the relative frequencies of the
individual trauma items. We then next examined the relationship between the frequency of
trauma types over time, since it is important to understand the cumulative burden of trauma.
As can be seen from Table 7 below, there was variation between the three sites over the past
few decades, and this variation corresponds to the known facts about events during these
times. For example, people living in Matabeleland were much more likely to suffer trauma in
the period 1980-1987 than people living in other Provinces, with the combination of the
mass violence accompanying Gukurahundi as well a number of very severe droughts during
the 1980s. Over the years Mutare shows greater frequencies of reported trauma than the
18
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents