An in-depth Study on the impacts of Operation Murambatsvina
period for detention was exceeded is notable. Here it is worth pointing out that this was
similarly reported during the Food Riots in 1998xliii.
Table 14 Effects on livelihoods
Given the recent High Court
Proportion
decision on the legality of police
[%]
action, and the high number of Operation interfered with livelihood
70%
persons arrested and assaulted, Registered traders
36%
there
must
be
some Traders paying rates to council
47%
consideration of redress for the Traders not given notice
84%
infringements of these citizens’ Mean days given as notice to stop
5-11 days
fundamental rights. This should trading
be in addition to redress for the Traders arrested
40%
losses incurred. However, here it Period in police custody
2.8 - 15 days
must be pointed out that there is Assaulted in police custody
27%
some urgency, as civil actions in Deaths/injuries as a result of
43%
Zimbabwean law are subject to demolitions
prescription in time, and it is Deaths/injuries as a result of police
43%
already 6 months since the actions
commencement
of
the
Operation. With less than 2 months remaining for registering civil claims, and as most of
those affected are without the means to pursue legal action, it is highly probable that the
victims of Operation Murambatsvina will lose their right to claim. This will be the grossest of
injustices.
4.5
Losses
Now much of the difficulty in estimating losses depends upon the unit of analysis: whether
the economic unit is the household or the individual. Additionally, estimates can also vary
according to the US$ exchange rate used: in the large ActionAid survey the Z$ rate to the
US$ was calculated at Z$1650 to US$1.
Working with households gives much lower estimates of losses, as is seen below in Tables 15
and 16.
Table 15: Losses of earnings & property
Loss of earnings
Table 15 reports
the actual figures
N=823[69%]
n=761[63%]
Total reported
Z$5,482,817,867.00 Z$23,463,846,404.00 obtained from
present
Average reported
Z$6,661,990.12
Z$30,832,912.49 the
survey.
Extrapolating these figures to the larger survey conducted by ActionAid, 69% represents
16,223 households with lost earnings, whilst 63% represents 14,812 households with losses
of property. Now as can be seen from Table 16, these figures are very similar to those
previously reported by ActionAid.
24
Loss of property
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents