whether or not the period ends on a Saturday,
Sunday or public holiday.15 Section 84 of the
Children’s Act [Chapter 5: 06] governs pre-trial
detention of children as follows:
“84 Detention of Juvenile
(1) A child or young person who is charged
with an offence shall not before
conviction be detained in a prison or
police cell or lock-up unless his detention
is necessary and no suitable remand home
is conveniently available for his detention.
(2) In deciding the suitability of any place
for the detention of a person mentioned in
subsection (1), regard may be had to the
nature of the offence with which he is
charged and to his age, sex, race and
character.”
The Constitution further provides that “no
person may be subjected to physical or
psychological torture or to cruel, inhuman or
degrading treatment or punishment.” 16 This right
is absolute and non-derogable. It provides that
no law may limit and no person may violate the
right not to be tortured or subjected to cruel,
inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.
The Constitution is supported by the Criminal
Law (Codification and Reform) Act [Chapter
9:23] (the Code), Criminal Procedure and
Evidence Act [Chapter 9:07] (CPE Act),
Children's Act [Chapter 5:06] and the Prisons Act
[Chapter 7:11]. These provide for substantive
and procedural protection to children who come
in contact with the law.
The Criminal Code contains the provisions on
criminal capacity. According to Section 6 of the
Criminal Code, “a child below the age of seven
years shall be deemed to lack the criminal
capacity and shall not be tried for or convicted of
any crime which he or she is alleged to have
committed before attaining that age.” Children
between the age of 7 years and 14 years are
presumed to lack the capacity to form the
intention to commit an offence. Alternatively,
where negligence is an element of the crime
concerned, they are presumed to lack the
capacity to behave in the way that a reasonable
adult would behave in the circumstances.17
This presumption may be rebutted depending
on the circumstances of each case. The onus is
on the State to establish beyond reasonable
doubt that the accused child was mature and did
understand that the act constituting the offence
was wrongful. Section 231 of the Criminal Code
however provides that “no proceedings in
respect of any crime shall be instituted or
continued against any person who is under the
age of fourteen years, other than proceedings for
the purpose of remand, without the authority of
the [Prosecutor]-General.”
Children above the age of 14 years are presumed
to have the capacity to form the necessary
intention to commit any crime or, where
negligence is an element of the crime
concerned, to behave in the way that a
reasonable person would have behaved in the
circumstances of the crime.18 These children can
therefore be tried for offences. There is therefore
no presumption of criminal incapacity for
children over the age of fourteen years. As such
they can be arrested and tried subject to
safeguards of them still being children below the
age of 18 years. The CPE Act compels a police
officer, unless otherwise directed by a
Magistrate, upon arresting a person under the
age of 18 years or warning such a person to
appear before the court, to warn the parent or
guardian of such a child to also appear in court.
This does not apply to a person who is under the
age of 18 years but emancipated in terms of the
law.19 A child’s parents or guardians must be
notified of the arrest of the child so as to ensure
their involvement early in the process and to
provide general psychological and emotional
assistance to the child during the proceedings.20
15. Section 50 (2) of the Constitution.
16. Section 53 of the Constitution.
17. Section 7 of the Criminal Code.
18. Section 8 of the Criminal Code.
19. Section 142(5) of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act [Chapter 9:07].
20. UN Committee of the Rights of the Child, General Comment No. 10 (2007) Children’s Rights in Juvenile Justice.
11 ‘Hear them Cry ’ – An Analysis of State Violence Against Children During the January 2019 Protests
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents