BALLOT
News
X
Issue No. 2
September 2007
ZIMBABWE
ELECTORAL
SYSTEM capable of healing
needs an
By Jealousy Mawarire
J
udging from past events, the Zimbabwe
political landscape is a minefield that has
generated acrimonious relations between
the two major political parties in Zimbabwe,
Zanu-PF and the Movement for Democratic
Change (MDC). Pre-election violence,
accusations and counter-accusations of
electoral fraud and litigations have
characterised the elections in Zimbabwe
since 2000. Such a political climate calls for
an electoral process capable of healing the
wounds resultant of the political tension
obtaining in the country since the dawning of
the new millennium.
There is need for an electoral process that
can create joyous losers, those that lose in
humility and rational enough to realise the
election is not all about winning but creating a
Zimbabwe that we want. May be the first
question would be what is and electoral
system?
An electoral system can easily be
understood as a way in which votes are
translated into seats. There are hundreds of
electoral systems currently in use and many
more permutations on each form. However,
there are three broad families of electoral
systems
• Majority Plurality Systems (First
Past The Post/FPTP; Block Vote;
A l t e r n a t i v e Vo t e ; Tw o r o u n d
System)
• Semi Proportional Systems
(Parallel; Limited Vote Single NonTransferable Vote/SNTV)
POLITICAL wounds
Political violence victim
• Proportional representation
systems (List PR; Mixed Member
Proportional, Single Transferable
Vote)
Zimbabwe's electoral system is a “first past
the post” system with single member
constituencies where the candidate with the
most votes wins a seat in the House of
Assembly/Senate.
While the system ensures accountability to
constituents for those elected, FPTP has,
however, tended to create outright winners
who care little about building bridges with
contesting parties. Therefore, used on its
own, FPTP tends to fail in the proposed task
of healing political wounds.
23
It is with this understanding that we propose
proportional representation to be merged to
FPTP to come up with the best electoral
system for the parliamentary vote, and PR
proper for the senate. Therefore, the Mixed
Member Proportional Representation
(MPPR), as used in Lesotho, would entail
that FPTP would be used for contested
parliamentary seats while PR would come
into force for compensatory seats which, in
the current situation, are occupied by nonconstituency MPs appointed by the
executive.
There is need to contextualise this call by
assessing the political situation since 2000.
The mood of bitterness in Zimbabwean
Continued on page 24
X
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents