GENDER AND THE POLITICS OF RECONCILIATION | DR HELEN SCANLON
created additional challenges to addressing the widespread
gender inequalities in South Africa and insert gender fully
into discussions on reconciliation. As such, South Africa
is testament that the liberal feminist ideals of increased
representation of women as key to transformation does not
hold true.
Apartheid’s Legacy
President Nelson Mandela was quick to identify the need
to address the structural and cultural obstacles to realising
gender equality in South Africa. In a speech on Women’s
Day in 1996 he observed:
“The legacy of oppression weighs heavily on
women. As long as women are bound by poverty
and as long as they are looked down upon, human
rights will lack substance. As long as outmoded
ways of thinking prevent women from making a
meaningful contribution to society, progress will be
slow. As long as the nation refuses to acknowledge
the equal role of more than half of itself, it is
doomed to failure”
However, despite the rhetoric, progress has been slow in
addressing the profound inequalities within South African
society beyond changes at the level of the law. As noted
above, South Africa is the most unequal nation in the world
and these inequalities remain primarily determined by race.
As Human Rights Watch has observed: “despite being a
middle income country, the key indicators of poverty for the
African population are equal to or worse than those for much
poorer countries elsewhere in Africa”.103 The international
NGO has detailed how “95 percent of those in the poorest
40 percent of the population are African and 65 percent of
Africans are poor, by the same measure”.104
To fully assess the extent of these inequalities it is important
to disaggregate by race and gender since African women
constitute both the lowest paid workers and the majority of
the unemployed in South Africa. As Hassim notes: “poverty
and inequality are deeply-gendered and inextricable
phenomena and to address them as if they were not is
misguided to say the least”.105 As many gender analysts
recognise the reform or restructuring of economic and
social structures is critical for reconciliation. Nonetheless,
in South Africa, African women have been bearing the
brunt of the increasing feminisation of poverty. Human
development indicators such as those embodied in the
2015 United Nations Millennium Development Goals have,
albeit inadvertently, highlighted African women’s continued
marginalisation. While there is now generally parity in
the educational achievement of men and women in South
Africa of those living under the food poverty line – defined
as less than R305 per month – the majority are African
women. According to the government’s 2013 Millennium
Development Goal Report women employees earn only
77 percent of the amount male employees earn and while
20 percent of women earned R1000 or less per month this
figure was only 10 percent among men.106 Women form
the majority of the country’s unemployed and in 2015 only
51 percent of the female population between the ages of 25
and 54 were employed.
The 2014 National Employment Equity Report noted that
in the private sector women constituted just 30 percent of
Senior Management in 2013 and only 20 percent in Top
Management.107 These statistics were confirmed by a July
2013 report by audit firm PwC that showed that women
constitute just ten percent of those on the Johannesburg Stock
Exchange and on average earn 28.1 percent less than men.
And although South Africa’s boasts progressive reproductive
health laws (over 90 percent of pregnant women have access
to antenatal care) levels of maternal mortality in South Africa
have increased to 625 deaths per 100000 live births in 2010.
Given that the UN MDG target was 38 per 100000 live births
by 2015 this figure clearly highlights changes to policies and
laws alone are not enough to address legacies of inequality
from the past.108 It is impossible to discuss gendered statistics
without acknowledging their racially skewed reality.
As discussed above, rates of gender-based violence in South
Africa are both contested and extraordinary. Crimes include
high incidences of sexual crimes -the South African Police
Service (SAPS) received 55,000 reports of rapes in 2010 but
the Medical Research Council claim that less than one in 25
rapes is reported to the police. According to Louise du Toit
40 percent of reported instances of sexual violence concern
“victims younger than eighteen years of age, and 15 percent
of all reported cases involve victims under age twelve.
About 84 percent of child rapes and 52 percent of adult
rapes involve perpetrators known to the victims”.109 She
also notes that there is no proper record of male rape victim
numbers. In addition rates of teenage male homicide are
extremely high but are nonetheless similar to the numbers
of adult male homicide.110
According to Louise du Toit, there are currently four, often
problematic but not mutually exclusive, interpretative
frameworks used to explain the high rates of sexual violence
in South Africa. The first is that of “past-perpetrator trauma”
whereby the prevalence of sexual violence is explained
through rationalisations centred on “masculinities in
crisis”, “colonial emasculation” or “precarious masculine
identities”.111 While not a justification for the current levels
of violence, it is clear that during apartheid there was
an acceptance of violent behaviour and, consequently,
widespread toleration of gender-based violence. A study
by the Medical Research Council has contended that the
state-sponsored violence perpetrated during the apartheid
era in conjunction with societal responses to this violence
has meant: “for many people, physical violence has become
a first line strategy for resolving conflict and gaining
ascendancy”.112
Louise du Toit notes that “social exclusion” due to socioeconomic marginalisation is the second explanation for
high levels of sexual violence. This locates the causal
factors for sexual violence in the present rather than the
past. The third explanation focuses on patriarchal politics
10
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents