Judgment No. SC 24/18
Civil Appeal No. SC 455/16
to define the issues and thereby to inform the parties in advance of the case they
have to meet and so enable them to take steps to deal with it.”
25.9
In a paper: A Judge’s View Point, the Role of Pleadings presented by Justices
Rares of the Federal Court of Australia and Richard White of the Supreme Court
of New South Wales at a judge’s symposium, the learned judges remarked:
“Precise formulation of the applicant’s rights in the initiating document is of
central importance. This is because the pleading is the source from which many
other consequences flow in the life of the litigation from filing at first instance
through to final resolution in the High Court. The pleading will be used as the
reference point for the seeking of particulars, the administering of
interrogatories (which is virtually extinct), the obtaining of an order for
discovery if the court is satisfied this is required, the issue of subpoenas, the
calling of evidence, the relevance and admissibility of evidence, the closing
arguments, the reasons for judgments and the availability of arguments on
appeal. At all of these points, the following questions arise: “Was this issue
pleaded?” and “How was this issue pleaded?” The question is not the loose one
whether the argument could possibly be raised on the evidence at the conclusion
of a hearing but whether the issue has been pleaded …”
[26]
I associate myself entirely with the above remarks made by eminent jurists both in this
jurisdiction and internationally. The position is therefore settled that pleadings serve
the important purpose of clarifying or isolating the triable issues that separate the two
litigants. It is on those issues that a defendant prepares for trial and that a court is called
upon to make a determination. Therefore a party who pays little regard to its pleadings
may well find itself in the difficult position of not being able to prove its stated cause
of action against an opponent.
REQUISITES FOR PLEADING A CONTRACT
[27]
In an action based on a contract, the material averments that must usually be made are
the existence of the contract, the relevant terms of the contract and the applicability of
those terms to the particular right forming the basis ex contractu of the claim –
13
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents