30
The independence of the judiciary since the June parliamentary elections has been under
sustained attack from the government. This has been accomplished by the government’s
defiance of High Court and Supreme Court orders, the attack upon the integrity of individual
judges, and the actual threat of assault and occupation of judges’ homes. Judges who have
shown any sign of judicial independence have also been threatened with investigation and
disciplinary action for supposed misconduct.xxx
The repercussions for handing down an independent judicial decision were certainly highlighted
when the Supreme Court finally decided the constitutionality of a presidential decree that banned
the MDC election challenges. Five days after the Supreme Court struck down the presidential
decree that aimed to thwart the MDC from bringing forth the election petitions, Chief Justice
Anthony Gubbay was forced into early retirement.xxxi Amid the public dispute that arose at that
time between the judiciary and the government, “war veterans” threatened to assault all judges
hostile to the government’s policies.xxxii Chinamasa and other Zanu (PF) officials vowed to
overhaul the judiciary, specifically targeting the remaining Supreme Court judges as well as four
non-black High Court judges. Black judges, who had made judgments against the state in the
past, would also be eliminated.xxxiii Chinamasa stated, “If they [judges] behave like unguided
missiles, I wish to emphatically state that we will push them out.”xxxiv
Shortly after Justice Devittie nullified the election of three Zanu (PF) parliamentarians and, amid
threats to him as a result, the judge tendered his resignation. Just before Devittie’s resignation, a
“war veteran leader”, Joseph Chinotimba stated, “Devittie is a judge for opposition parties. The
way Gubbay went is the same way Devittie is gong to go.” xxxv
Since then High Court judges, Justice Esmael Chatikobo, Justice Michael Gillespie, and Justice
David Bartlett and Supreme Court judge, Justice Nicholas McNally have either resigned or
retired. Four new judges with Zanu (PF) links were appointed. xxxvi
Since the Judge President, Justice Godfrey Chidyausiku, was promoted to the position of Acting
Chief Justice in the wake of Gubbay’s departurexxxvii, the government decided to promote Justice
Paddington Garwe ahead of more senior High Court judges, such as Justice George Smith and
Justice Mohamed Adam both who have been targeted by the government in their moves to purge
the judiciary.xxxviii Additionally, Justice Vernanda Ziyambi was elevated to the Supreme Court in
August 2001.
Still, judges have remained resilient in the face of enormous adverse pressure. On political
violence, Justice Moses Chinhengo stated, “Violence as a means to an end has entered and
lodged itself in the national psyche. It must be exorcised…we need peace and tranquility when
we elect our leaders during national elections.” xxxix On attacks on the judiciary, Justice Chatikobo
stated, “Judges and magistrates cannot discharge their duties properly if they are subject to
direction or control from …the government of the day…the courts [need] to administer the laws of
the country without fear, favour or prejudice, independently of the consequences which might
ensue.”xl
xxx
Gillespie, J. The State v. Tapfuma Humbarume and Ask Ndoro p.4
Zimbabwe Human Rights Bulletin, p.24
xxxii
The Standard, 18-24 February 2001, p.1
xxxiii
The Standard, 11-17, p.1; The Standard, 18-24, p.1; The four non-black judges that were targeted were, Justice
George Smith, Justice Michael Gillespie, Justice Fergus Blackie and Justice James Devittie. Two black judges that
condemned the government’s interference and intimidation of the judiciary were Justice Esmael Chatikobo and Justice
Moses Chinhengo.
xxxiv
The Daily News, February 6, 2001, p.2
xxxv
The Eastern Star, May 4, 2001
xxxvi
The Daily News, December 22, 2000, p.1-2: Ben Hlatswayo, Rita Makarau, Anne Gowora, and Charles Hungwe
xxxvii
The Standard, 24-30 June p.1
xxxviii
The Standard, February 25-March 3, 2001 p.1
xxxix
The Daily News, February 7, 2001, p.1
xl
The Daily News, February 27, 2001, p.3
xxxi
AMANI TRUST: Neither Free nor Fair: High Court decisions on the petitions on the June 2000 General Election.
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents