7
Murambatsvina indicates, by any ameliorative mechanisms, but rather by rigorous enforcement
of legislation designed to prevent dissent by sectors of the populace which the government
seems to fear are approaching a position where they have little left to lose.
The 2005 Operation Murambatsvina continues to have grave social impacts upon the urban poor 6
and in recent months the government has mounted further Murambatsvina-like operations in
different parts of the country.
THE BENCHMARKS CONSIDERED
Resumption of constructive dialogue between ZANU-PF and MDC
This basic benchmark, which may be the key to meeting the others, has not been approached at
all. The opposition split into two factions in October 2005. President Robert Mugabe has not
sought to use this split to avoid dialogue on the ground that there is no clarity as to with whom
he should negotiate. Instead, Mugabe has continued to insist that the opposition MDC is a front
for the British Government’s intention to seeking regime change and that negotiations must
therefore be between himself and his British counterpart. A clear instance of this approach was
manifested in July, 2006 when the Zimbabwean government withdrew an invitation to the United
Nations Secretary General Kofi Annan to visit Zimbabwe after reports that Annan was seeking to
play a role in resolving the Zimbabwe crisis. Thereafter, reports circulated widely that President
Benjamin Mkapa (a long time vocal supporter of Mugabe) would play the role of a mediator, not
between ZANU-PF and the MDC, but between Britain and Zimbabwe. Mkapa subsequently denied
having taken up this role. Indeed, Mkapa has done nothing to indicate that he had such a
mandate7. Accordingly, there have been no negotiations at all between ZANU-PF and the MDC in
the period under review8.
Political intimidation and violence
Political violence and intimidation is most evident during election periods and during major
demonstrations or meetings held by opposition groupings (see below). There were two
Parliamentary By-Elections over the period in review and Rural District Council elections. Far from
an adherence to the SADC Guidelines, these elections were conducted in a manner to which
Zimbabweans have become accustomed. The By-Elections were in ZANU-PF strongholds, and as
happened in past elections in these constituencies, ZANU- PF declared them virtual no go areas
6
7
8
See, for instance, Political repression disguised as civic mindedness: Operation Murambatsvina one year later
Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum November 2006.
“Mkapa Initiative Dead in the Water” Financial Gazette 9/11-16/11/06
“More of Mugabe’s Magic Tricks” Pretoria News (South Africa) 04/09/06
Zimbabwe’s Failure to meet the Benchmarks in the Contonou Agreement