An in-depth Study on the impacts of Operation Murambatsvina
4.1.3 Variation in types of trauma
As can be seen from Table 5 below, there is wide variation in the types of traumatic events
reported by the sample as a whole. Lack of food or water, ill-health without access to medical care, lack
of shelter, any other situation that was very frightening or feeling that life was in danger, and confiscation or
destruction of property were significantly more frequent than any other types of trauma reported.
Additionally, feeling dependent on others was also markedly more frequent, and all of these
together indicate the traumatic consequences of Operation Murambatsvina. As pointed out
earlier, most of these items were included because of their hypothesized salience to Operation
Murambatsvina, and this effect was found in fact. As can also be seen from Table 5, items
related to organized violence and torture were also reported with a relatively high frequency.
Torture, imprisonment, and severe beatings were reported with much the same frequency as in the
reports of human rights organizations, but the traumas of ordinary life - motor traffic
accidents, industrial accident, rape and sexual abuse other than rape – are less commonly
reported. Although there is variation across the three sites, the rankings for thee frequencies
of the various items were remarkably consistent and statistically significant [see Table 5
below].
Table 5: Frequency of responses on Trauma Questionnaire:
Experiences only [Percentages & Ranks] [n=1195]
Number
Lack of food or water
915
Ill health without access to medical care
580
Lack of shelter
536
Imprisonment
236
Serious injury
247
Caught up in combat
325
Rape
79
Forced isolation from others
273
Being close to death
320
Forced separation from family members
350
Murder of family or friends
97
Unnatural death of family or friends
195
Murder of stranger or strangers
48
Lost or kidnapped
110
Severe beatings
392
Torture
293
Motor traffic accident
206
Industrial accident
152
Natural disaster(flood, fire, etc)
438
Any other situation that was very frightening
586
or you felt that your life was in danger
Confiscation or destruction of property
582
Sexual abuse other than rape
172
Feeling dependent on others
436
Percentage & Ranks
76.6% [1]
48.9% [3]
44.9% [5]
19.8% [16]
20.7% [15]
27.2% [10]
6,.6% [22]
22.9% [14]
26.8% [11]
29.3% [9]
8.1% [21]
16.3% [17]
4.02% [23]
9.2%[20]
32.8% [8]
24.5% [12]
24.5% [12]
12.7% [19]
36.7% [6]
49.1% [2]
48.7% [4]
14.4% [18]
36.5% [7]
Table 6 below shows the comparative frequency of responses for the 3 sites sampled. As can
be seen, there is the general trend towards Harare reporting more frequent trauma than
17
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents