An in-depth Study on the impacts of Operation Murambatsvina
Table 3: Comparison of scores over sample sites
SRQ-8
Total
Score on
Trauma
OVT items
Score
Harare
5.4[2.3]
6.9[4.5]
1.5[1.7]
[n=570]
Bulawayo
3.7[2.5]
5.2[3.7]
1.2[1.5]
[n=386]
Mutare
4.9[2.5]
6.7[3.6]
1.5[1.5]
[n=239]
Total:
4.8[2.5]
6.3[4.2]*
1.4[1.6]*
Score on
OM
items
3.4[2.2]
No. of
different years
affected
3.8[1.4]
2.6[1.7]
4.1[1.4]
3.1[2.03]
4.5[1.3]
3.1[2.03]*
4.03[1.4]*
*xxxix
As can be seen in Table 3 above, there are regional variations in the scores derived from the
questionnaires, but, overall, there are significant relationships between the probability of
psychological disorder and the total number of trauma events reported [Total Trauma
Score], the number of trauma events indicative of violence [OVT items], the number of
trauma events indicative of displacement [OM items], and the number of different time
periods in which trauma was experienced. As can be seen [footnote 24 below] the strongest
relationship was with OM items on the Trauma Questionnaire.
Therefore, our data show the following:
•
•
•
•
A significant relationship between current psychological disorder and the
number of trauma events reported;
A significant relationship between current psychological disorder and
trauma due to OVT [organized violence and torture];
A significant relationship between current psychological disorder and
trauma due to displacement events [OM items];
A significant relationship between current psychological disorder and
repeated exposure to trauma.
Thus, our data indicate that the severity of trauma, the effects of OVT and displacements
[OM items], and the number of times trauma is experienced are all significantly related to
psychological disorder. There is, thus, a “dose-response” effect found, and Operation
Murambatsvina has contributed significantly to this effect.
Table 4: Correlations between SRQ-8 and Total Trauma score per year
<1980
1980-1987
1990-1997
1998-2000
2001-2004
2005
0.034
0.022
0.064*
0.098**
0.11**
0.113**
*p=0.01; **p=0.05
Finally, as can be seen from Table 4 above, there are interesting relations between
psychological disorder and the contribution of trauma reported by time period. The
strongest relationship is with trauma reported in 2005, but the trend is towards increasing
levels since the 1990s.
16
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents