members were as likely to report violations outside election period as during elections. NCA, the
Combined Harare Residents’ Association [CHRA], and the ZCTU members were targets outside of
elections.
As regards the violations themselves, police stations were significantly associated with unlawful
arrest, unlawful detention, and torture, whilst death threats, property destruction, interference
with freedoms, kidnapping [abductions], political intimidation, and displacement usually occur in
places other than police stations. The number of different violations reported was significantly
greater in those who reported that the violations had taken place at police stations, and
violations were more likely to occur at police stations at non-election times.
Property destruction and displacements were associated with elections, as has been frequently
noted before, whilst only death threats were more common outside of election periods. All the
other types of violation were as likely to occur during elections as at other times.
There were interesting differences between rural and urban areas. Violations in the rural areas
were more frequently reported for the years 2001 (the lead-up to the Presidential election), 2002
(the year of the Presidential Election), and 2003. The pattern then reversed and violations were
more likely in the urban areas, such as in 2005, when both a Parliamentary election and
Operation Murambatsvina took place. There were also significant differences between the two
groups – rural and urban - in the frequency with which violations took place at police stations,
with the urban group more frequently reporting violations at police stations.
Members of the MDC were more likely to report their violation having occurred in the rural areas,
as was the case with those who had no expressed affiliation, and these two groups accounted for
over 75% of the rural sample. All the other activist groups were more likely to have reported a
violation taking place in an urban area. Apart from property destruction and displacements, most
other violations were more frequently reported in those victim cases from the urban areas.
Assault, unlawful arrest, unlawful detention, and torture were significantly more common in the
urban group. Furthermore, urban victims reported experiencing different types of violations than
victims from the rural areas, and here the trend towards an increasing frequency of violations in
2006 must be noted again.
As regards activism, non-activists were more likely to report a violation in 2002, the year of the
Presidential election, and a time when partisanship was running extremely high, but there is a
shift towards activists being more frequently targeted during 2006, which compliments the more
general findings that violations are dramatically increasing in 2006 [see Table 1 ]. Activists were
Who guards the guards? Violations by the Zimbabwe Republic Police, 2000 to 2006
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents