2. Preparation for Developing a Human Rights
Violation Database
Existing human rights data sources
The research sought to develop a profile of existing human rights data with a view to determining
what might be utilised for the development of a human rights violation database, with an emphasis
on primary data sources (statements, interviews and other narratives). The following profile,
however, includes a range of data sources. (The following section – 3 – deals with related qualitative
reports on the human rights situation in Zimbabwe.)
Although the writer was looking at information from both colonial and post-independence periods,
it is evident that there is considerably more information available relating to the post-independence
period, and in particular to violations in Matabeleland and the Midlands in the 1980s and in
relation to the post 2000 era. This certainly reflects the key periods of repression in the independent
Zimbabwe. The project had less success in locating primary data from the colonial era. In this regard,
there was some difficulty in determining where and in what condition the archives of the Catholic
Commission for Justice and Peace in Rhodesia were.
There has been a significant increase in data collection in the post 2000 period, with many more
organisations involved in monitoring and documenting human rights developments and violations,
and covering a range of issues, civil and political, social and economic. This has resulted in both a
greater degree of co-operation between different human rights organisations, as evidenced by the
establishment of the Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum, but also in a degree of duplication
(e.g. a number of organisations are involved in newspaper monitoring, even though the MMPZ
provides the most comprehensive service in this regard and could have been employed to provide
this information.)
Data is largely metropolitan centred (Harare and Bulawayo), reflecting the operational focus of
most monitoring organisations, and the difficulties of access to many parts of the country. There
are some notable exceptions to this, such as one Harare-based organisation, which has monitors in
every constituency of the country. Although information from the provinces is certainly recorded,
this often comes from individual victims and survivors who have been able to seek relief in the
cities and other urban centres. Consequently, many interviewees felt that a significant number of
violations, especially in the rural areas, have not been captured.
A number of organisations have been involved in the monitoring and documenting human rights
violations. Details of what organisations have collected what information have been gathered in
this research process, and the information has been made available to relevant parties. For obvious
reasons, this information cannot be made publicly available in the current circumstances, as there are
vested interests that would want to sabotage and destroy these sources. Nevertheless, a considerable
amount of this information is already public. The sources of this information include:
Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum
The Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum was established in 1998 and has been responsible for the
production of monthly incident reports and other specialist reports relating to organised violence
and torture. The Forum provides the main platform for most NGOs involved in monitoring and
documenting human rights violations to pool their data in a collaborative endeavour designed to
provide a regular overview of reported and recorded violations from across the country.
32
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents