CHAPTER XIV
G ENERAL DEFENCES AND M ITIGATING F ACTORS
PART I
P RELIMINARY
213 Interpretation in Chapter XIV
In this Chapter
“complete defence” means a defence to a criminal charge which completely absolves the accused from
criminal liability;
“partial defence” means a defence to a criminal charge which does not completely absolve the accused from
criminal liability but instead renders the accused liable to conviction for a lesser crime.
214 Defences and mitigating factors not limited to those mentioned in Chapter XIV
The defences and mitigating factors which an accused may successfully raise are not limited to those set out
in this Chapter.
215 Defence to one crime not necessarily defence to other crimes
The fact that a person has a complete or partial defence in relation to conduct which is an essential element of
a particular crime shall not prevent that person from being charged with and convicted of any other crime of
which that conduct is not an essential element.
Division A: Defence Relating to Voluntary Conduct
PART II
AUTOMATISM
216 Involuntary conduct
(1) Subject to subsection (3), the fact that the conduct of a person charged with a crime was not voluntary as
required by paragraph (c) of section nine, that is, that the person did or omitted to do anything that is an essential
element of the crime without conscious knowledge or control, shall be a complete defence to the charge.
(2) Without derogating from the generality of the meaning of “voluntary conduct”, the following do not
constitute voluntary conduct
(a) a reflex movement, spasm or convulsion;
(b) a bodily movement during unconsciousness or sleep;
(c) conduct during hypnosis, or which results from hypnotic suggestion;
(d) conduct over which a person has no control, his or her body or part of his or her body being merely an
instrument in the hands of a human or natural agency outside him or her;
and the expression “involuntary conduct” shall be construed accordingly.
(3) If a situation in which a person’s conduct is involuntary is brought about through the person’s own fault,
a court may regard the conduct as voluntary.
(4) If it is found that the conduct of a person upon which he or she is charged with a crime was involuntary,
and that such involuntary conduct was the result of a mental disorder or defect as defined in section two hundred
and twenty-six, a court shall return a special verdict in terms of section 29 of the Mental Health Act [Chapter
15:12] (Act No. 15 of 1996).
Division B: Defences and Mitigating Factors Relating to the Mental State
PART III
DIMINISHED R ESPONSIBILITY
217 Interpretation in Part III of Chapter XIV
In this Part
“partial mental disorder or defect” means a mental disorder or defect as defined in section two hundred and
twenty-six, the effect of which is not such as to entirely deprive the person suffering from it of the
capacity to appreciate the nature or lawfulness of his or her conduct or to act in accordance with such an
appreciation.
218 Diminished responsibility to operate in mitigation not as defence
(1) If at the time when a crime is committed the capacity of the person committing it
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents