13
Judgment No. CCZ 3/18
Constitutional Application No. CCZ 15/18
In De Lacy and Another v South African Post Office 2011 (9) BCLR 905 (CC) at
para [50] the Court of South Africa, whilst considering the approach in the application of the
provisions of s 167(6) of the Constitution of South Africa, remarked:
“[50] Section 167(6) of the Constitution requires this Court to allow a person to
bring a matter directly should it be in the interests of justice to do so. Where the interests
of justice lie depends on the outcome of a meticulous weighing-up of relevant
considerations. Chief of these, but not solely decisive, would be whether there are
prospects of success. For instance, the public importance of the issue raised or its impact
on the administration of justice may well favour granting direct access in a matter in
which prospects of success may be open to some doubt.” (my emphasis)
See also Dormehl v Minister of Justice and Others 2000 (2) SA 987 (CC).
The applicants seek in the main application an order interdicting the President from
proclaiming the dates for the harmonised general elections. Paragraph 12 of the founding
affidavit states:
“12. This is an application wherein the applicants are seeking an order to have
the first respondent hold the pronouncement of election dates until the Political Parties
Finance Act is repealed since it is ultra vires the Constitution as it does not protect the
other political parties, especially section 3 that says ‘… each political party whose
candidates received at least five per centum of the total number of votes cast in the most
recent general election’ …”.
Paragraph 1 of the draft order relates to the same relief.
Section 144(1) of the Constitution, in terms of which the President is to act in setting
the dates for the harmonised general elections, is mandatory. It provides:
“144 General election resulting from dissolution of Parliament
(1)
Where Parliament has not earlier passed resolutions to dissolve in terms
of section 143(2), the President must by proclamation call and set dates for a general
election to be held within the period prescribed in section 158.”