Unlawful procedures and acts in the arrest, detention, and
deportation of undocumented foreigners
Officers’ failure to verify the status and identity of suspected “illegal
foreigners”
The Immigration Act and Immigration Regulations provide that an immigration or
police officer must assist an individual apprehended on suspicion of being illegally in the
country to verify his or her identity or status, including by accessing readily available
relevant documents or contacting relatives or others who could prove the individual’s
identity and status.86
At Makhado (Louis Trichardt) police station, a police officer described to Human Rights
Watch the role of the Department of Home Affairs with respect to illegal immigrants
who were detained in the police cells: “We call the Home Affairs Department to come
and check illegals’ documents. If Home Affairs finds the documents okay, Home
Affairs is the one to release him. Maybe the person doesn’t have his document. Maybe
the next day, the friend will bring the passport or document. Home Affairs must be the
one to release.”87
Detainees in the Makhado police cell told Human Rights Watch that no officials had
visited them. Many had been arrested the previous day, but one detainee had spent 19
days and another over three months in the police cell. A Zimbabwean from Bulawayo
who had been working on a farm related how he had not been given an opportunity to
retrieve his work permit: “I’ve been working there [on the farm] six years. It’s along the
Thohoyandou road. I’m the only Zimbabwean on that farm. After 12 days I get R560
[US$80]. I was arrested yesterday. I have a work permit at work. I asked them this
morning to phone my home to ask them to bring the document but they did not.
Nobody at home even knows where I am.”88 Another Zimbabwean detainee said his
South African wife had taken his ID when she left him: “I was married to a South
African, with a child. I am working here since 1999. She left with the ID. I went to
Home Affairs. They have fingerprints, etc. but they did nothing. How can I get my ID
back?”89
86
Immigration Act, as amended by Immigration Amendment Act, section 41(1) and Immigration Regulations,
section 32.
Human Rights Watch interview with a police official, Makhado police station, Makhado, April 29, 2006.
88
Human Rights Watch interview with a Zimbabwean detainee awaiting deportation, Makhado police station,
Makhado, April 29, 2006.
89
Ibid.
87
23
HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH VOLUME 18. NO. 6(A)
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents