GENDER AND THE POLITICS OF RECONCILIATION | DR HELEN SCANLON
Abstract
Twenty-two years into South Africa’s democracy debates have re-emerged over the limitations
of discourses on reconciliation in the country. This stems from the fact that in the two decades
since South Africa’s first free and fair elections a widening chasm has emerged between the
promises of “reconcilation” and the realities of on-going widespread poverty and inequalities.
Indeed, South Africa’s beleaguered transformation is particularly apparent in terms of the
prevalent level of gender-based violence, often cited as the highest in the world, as well as
the ongoing feminisation of poverty. As such, important questions have arisen following
South Africa’s transition over what is needed for a “gender-inclusive” reconciliation.
Reconciliation, while a contested term, can potentially fulfil a number of practical and
symbolic purposes of acknowledging the harm inflicted upon victims and promoting social
equity and human rights. According to gender activists effective reconciliation has the potential
to facilitate post-conflict transformation of socio-cultural injustices and inequalities which
inevitably will promote greater gender equality. Nonetheless critiques of reconciliation have
centred on it being elite driven, that it benefits particular interest groups and that it imposes
undue burden on victims for the restoration and transformation of society. Furthermore it is
argued that it has contributed to shifts in the “geography of violence” resulting in the increase
of interpersonal violence.
This paper explores how attempts to confront abusive pasts have deliberated gender in
the promotion of reconcilation. In particular it will examine the nexus between gender
justice and reconciliation in order to assess and considers ways to re-calibrate engagement
with ongoing reconciliation processes. Given current debates over revisiting the promise of
reconciliation in South Africa it is an opportune time to reflect on how reconciliation could
better confront histories of gendered harms.