ActionAid International - Combined Harare Residents’ Association - A Study on the impact of “Operation
Murambatsvina/Restore Order”
Harareans sought to mitigate the accommodation problem. The Operation destroyed
structures that were deemed as illegal in Harare’s high density areas. More than three
quarters (3/4) of the respondents reported losing shelter. If this is the case, due to the
strain and the exorbitant rental rates that the landlords charge, the family unit is exposed
to further economic strain. It worrying to note that over 40% of homesteads visited
reported that family units had been disrupted as a result of the operation. Mostly children
and spouses had been relocated back to the rural homesteads if this was plausible.
3.3.9 Women status and dignity
Humiliation and loss of dignity as a direct result of the operation was also reported. Prior
to the demolition exercise, it is reported and accounted by respondents that the
authorities would move around marking what they deemed as illegal structures using
paint. The marked buildings were to be destroyed. Such actions resemble a war situation.
Therefore, naturally, women primarily as custodians of the family, were victims of such
draconian measures. This is witnessed by 39% of the interviewed homesteads claiming
that they had lost their dignity as a result of the Operation.
3.3.10 Increased vulnerability for children, orphans and women
In a disaster (natural or man made in this case) children and women are more vulnerable
to abuse and exploitation. It is saddening to note that 37% of the interviewed
homesteads acknowledged that women and children had become more vulnerable to
abuse as a consequence of the Operation. Furthermore, a high proportion of the these
were from female-headed households. A major problem that normally ensues is sexual
exploitation as women try to fend for children. As earlier highlighted, the majority of
child headed households are girls. This not only reinforces the earlier statement that they
are increasingly becoming vulnerable.
3.3.11 Psychologically affected (traumatized)
The operation was swiftly implemented without prior warning in most wards. Heavy
machinery such as bull dozers and trucks were rolled out. To complement this armed
police and riot personnel participated in the Operation. The scale of the Operation in
some instances resembled a war situation. As a result almost 40% of respondents
interviewed claimed that they had been traumatized by the graphic, detailed and heavy
handedness of the implementers of the Operations. From the analysis done, this was
generally the same across board. Despite the low proportion of child headed households,
this seemed to be reported in 82% of child headed households.
3.4
Coping mechanisms being employed by affected communities
Coping mechanisms are behavioural changes made at household level to adjust to
unexpected and expected shocks. It becomes extremely prudent to establish how
households are coping as a result of the sheer magnitude of the operation. Coping
mechanisms employed paint a good picture on the vulnerability status of the affected
communities. Currently, only 37% households reported that they were using their own
resources to sustain the family. A further 22% claimed to be getting assistance from
relatives, whilst government, community based organizations and non-governmental
organizations accounted for a mere 6% (see Figure 2). More importantly is the realization
that 35% of households were not receiving any assistance at all and described themselves
as not managing the situation at all. In this bracket, the majority were child- and women
headed households accounting for 76% of the responses. This proportion is in urgent
need of assistance, whilst those that are being supported by relative may not be in
11
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents