clear a consensus as the prohibition of torture inhuman and
degrading treatment of a person in the custody of a public
official. That such a treatment should never form part of the
techniques of investigation of crimes employed by law
enforcement agents, is a restatement of the principle that the
law which it is their duty to enforce, requires that only fair and
humane treatment ought to be applied to a person under
criminal investigation.”
9.1.4 The findings reveal that following the altercations between the police
and touts at the Chiremba turnoff bus stop on the 4th of July 2016,
the police instigated systematic torture i.e. torture which was
organized in that it targeted men on the basis that the touts, who
were men, had fought the police, and therefore to punish the touts or
men in the immediate residential place of Chiremba bus turnoff bus
stop for an act committed or suspected of having been committed by
them.
9.1.4.1
Torture was perpetrated through beating with baton sticks,
including falanga, i.e. beating under the feet, beating with
open hands, kicking with boots and unleashing of police dogs
on men. Torture, in accordance with the definition and
elements discussed above were satisfied by the actions of the
police.
9.1.4.2
Despite the touts having attacked the police, it is important to
observe and reiterate the interpretation that was given by the
Supreme court in the Mukoko case (supra) that “No
exceptional circumstance such as the seriousness of the
crime the person is suspected of having committed, or the
danger he or she is believed to pose to national security can
justify infliction of torture, or inhuman or degrading treatment.
(Emphasis added)
9.1.4 The amount of force, evidenced by the injuries sustained by some of the
Complainants as corroborated by medical experts interviewed reveal a case
of Police Brutality. Police Brutality is defined as;
“The use of excessive and/or unnecessary force by police when
dealing with civilians. “Excessive use of force” means a force well
beyond what would be necessary in order to handle a situation.”4
4
The Law Dictionary, available online at http://thelawdictionary.org/article/what-is-police-brutality/.
Page 30 of 37
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents