SADC leaders have taken the first important step of publicly stating the need for Zimbabwe
to establish preconditions for the holding of credible, free and fair elections. These have
been strong words from the SADC, but words not backed by action. Successive SADC
resolutions on Zimbabwe have gone without implementation.
It is the lack of a robust implementation mechanism for its decisions that severely
weakens the SADC’s positive stand on Zimbabwe. SADC leaders have failed to maintain
pressure on ZANU-PF and other GPA partners to implement agreed GPA reforms and create
the environment for the holding of elections that fully comply with SADC’s principles and
guidelines on the conduct of democratic elections.
Should the unity government fail to take appropriate steps to institute key human rights
reforms ahead of the elections, the SADC should lead the international community in
taking appropriate and effective measures against those unity government officials
responsible. Although the SADC Principles and Guidelines Governing Democratic Elections
are simply guidelines with no legal force, the SADC still has a range of measures that it can
invoke against those responsible for the violation of its standards including suspension of
a state from membership and imposition of sanctions.76
To effectively promote adherence to the GPA, the SADC should, in line with its principles
and guidelines on the conduct of democratic elections, ensure that it closely observes and
monitors Zimbabwe’s next elections. Prior to the calling of elections, the SADC should
independently examine conditions on the ground and certify that the environment is
conducive to the holding of democratic elections. The SADC Election Observer Mission for
the June 2008 presidential runoff election concluded that “the pre-election phase was
characterized by politically motivated violence, intimidation, and displacements,” and that
the process leading up to the presidential run-off elections held on June 27, 2008, did not
conform to SADC Principles and Guidelines Governing Democratic Elections, although the
election day was peaceful.77 The SADC should deploy its observer mission in Zimbabwe
early and in sufficient numbers to facilitate effective monitoring of the pre-election period
that has in the past been characterized by violence and intimidation.
76 SADC suspended Madagascar from membership following a military coup there in March 2009.
77 SADC 2008 runoff election Observer Mission Report, Harare, June 29, 2008.
27
HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH | JANUARY 2013
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents