14
studies2, and this group had a considerably higher number of symptoms. This was probably due
to the combination of physical and psychological injuries.
The scores obtained from the Self-Reporting Questionnaire (SRQ-8) and the Harvard Trauma
Scale (HTS) additionally show that this group had experienced psychological problems as a
consequence of their alleged torture. The SRQ-8 is a psychiatric screening instrument, and all
scores in excess of 4/8 are strongly indicative of clinically significant psychological disorder.
Fifteen (36%) members of the sample reported scores in excess of 4/8, which is lower than other
Zimbabwean samples, but is undoubtedly due to the fact that most people experienced only a
single experience.
The sample reported more experiences of trauma than witnessing or hearing stories on the
Harvard Trauma Scale. Only 7 (47%) persons of the clinically disordered group showed signs of
PTSD, but this was a much higher percentage than other Zimbabwean studies, and undoubtedly
reflects the acute nature of the psychological distress. PTSD would be more strongly expected as
an immediate consequence of OVT than other forms of disorder.
The victims from the Food Riots in 1998 were different in many ways to the sample from the
19870s War of Liberation. In most respects their treatment was less severe than those from the
Liberation War, and was confined to a single episode of torture or injury due to gunshot wound.
However, it is significant that they clearly suffered from the experience and many were
psychologically disturbed by the experience. The data did support the claims that torture had
been inflicted and that gross human rights violations had taken place. This report has
subsequently been validated by the results of the court cases that have taken place, where the
majority of the claims have been upheld by the courts and damages awarded. In some of the
cases, the judges have made very strong statements about the use of torture and indiscriminate
and irresponsible use of firearms.
5.
Victims from the 2000 Parliamentary Elections
During the 2000 Parliamentary Elections in Zimbabwe, there were a very large number of reports
made of gross human rights violations being perpetrated by the supporters of the Zanu(PF)
government. These reports were made by local observer groups such as the Human Rights
Forum, the Zimbabwe Election Support Network (ZESN), and the Zimbabwe Civic Education
Trust (Zimcet), as well as by international human rights organisations and election observer
groups. A number of the victims of OVT were referred to the AMANI Trust for medical assistance.
This has been documented in detail in a number of reports dealing with the Parliamentary
Elections3, and it is not our intention to summarise the enormous detail relating to human rights
violations and electoral irregularities here. Additionally, many of the issues related to the
psychological distress suffered by the victims and the issues related to some of them testifying in
the Zimbabwe High Court to their experiences have been described elsewhere 4. Here we will
confine ourselves to some quantitative observations about the victims from the Parliamentary
Elections. This summary is based upon the victims seen by the Amani Trust.
2
See HALL, A., & WILLIAMS, H. (1987)(a), Hidden psychiatric morbidity. Part I: Study of prevalence in an outpatient
population at Bindura Provincial Hospital, Central African Journal Of Medicine., 33, 239; REELER,A.P., WILLIAMS,H., &
TODD,C.,H.,(1993), Psychopathology in Primary Care patients: A four-year study in rural and urban settings, Central
African Journal Of Medicine, 39, 1-8; PATEL, V., TODD, C., WINSTON, M. ET AL (1997), Common mental disorders in
primary care in Harare, Zimbabwe: associations and risk factors, Brit.J.Psychiat., 171, 60-64.
3
See AMANI (2002), Neither Free nor Fair: High Court decisions on the petitions on the June 2000 General Election,
HARARE: AMANI TRUST; AMANI (2002), Organised Violence and Torture in the Bye-Elections held in Zimbabwe during
2000 and 2001, HARARE: AMANI TRUST.
4
See AMANI (2002), Heroism in the Dock: Does testifying help victims of organised violence and torture? A pilot study
from Zimbabwe, HARARE: AMANI TRUST; AMANI (2002), “At the boiling point of the pain”. Report of a pilot study
examining the efficacy of psychotherapy for torture survivors, HARARE: AMANI.
AMANI TRUST: Beating your opposition. Torture during the 2002 Presidential campaign in Zimbabwe.
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents