looking at a simple causal relationship between conflict, violence and mental health, as many
practitioners in Africa have observed.xxxvii Where mental health records are available for consultation,
as in Northern Ireland for example, the psychological effect of prolonged conflict is not clear.
Reactions to violence and torture are deeply intertwined with the meaning which people give to what
has happened, with cultural and spiritual beliefs and with the ongoing context.
An early series of studies gives some understanding of the morbid profile. In a study of former
freedom fighters, it was found that the diagnostic breakdown did not strongly support the view that
PTSD was the common form of psychological morbidity. There were strong similarities between the
pattern observed in combatant and non-combatant survivors.
Table 4: Diagnoses given to Mount Darwin Community survivors: Comparison with
Zimbabwe War Veterans.
PTSD
Anxiety Depression
Mixed
Somatoform
Emotional
Disorder
Disorder
Mashonaland
24%
1%
21%
32%
21%
Central
[n=179]
War Veterans
28%
4%
12%
33%
24%
[n=53]
It is worth pointing out, in the light of the more recent research cited above, that both Depression and
PTSD were frequent diagnoses, but also it is important to understand that the equally high rates of Mixed
Emotional Disorder (or what would be termed Common Mental Disorder in more recent terminology) and
Somatoform Disorder. It is probable that a more carefully designed study would provide a different
typology, but it also the case that Common Mental Disorders [CMD] have been found to be a substantial
category of psychological disorder in primary care settings, and also that multiple symptoms are a very
common presenting profile of persons with psychological disorder Zimbabwe. It is also worth pointing out
that previous work on torture survivors in Zimbabwe suggested that the multiple symptom presentation
seemed to cover both physical symptoms from pain due to chronic injury – back ache, for example - as
well as the more common symptoms associated with psychological disorder – headache, stomach pains,
etc.xxxviii
There have been few clinical studies of character of psychological disorders due to OVT or PTE‘s. One
qualitative study outlined the interactions between the psychological distress and the social
disempowerment suffered by the survivors attending for psychotherapy.xxxix Amongst the men there
was significant guilt at failing to protect themselves and their families, exacerbated by the
impoverishment due to displacement that frequently accompanied the violence. And, furthermore, it was
evident that the suffering was not merely individual or familial, but had profound consequences for the
communities in which the violence had taken place, and for the forms of healing deemed most helpful by
sufferers (typically spiritual). This is the destruction of ―social capital‖ indicated by Mollica and others that
is a common feature of complex emergencies.
Thus, there is a pressing need for good research into the nature of disorders due to trauma in Zimbabwe,
of individuals, families, and communities, And there is equally a pressing need to examine critically the
varied approaches to treatment that have been and are currently in use. This needs to include, as
already indicated, both a broader assessment to include functionality, resilience and protective factors, a
locally validated PTSD assessment tool, and indicators to help identify how villages and communities
have been affected by events. With more focused assessment tools and a deeper understanding of the
nature of trauma in Zimbabwe, it should be possible to build constructively on the extensive work done
by the Amani Trust to research the effects of individual clinical work in primary care. As rising levels of
distress can often be clearly linked to the deteriorating context, research is also needed to develop
understanding of the kinds of social and community initiatives, and ways of working, including use of
existing traditions and beliefs, which can be shown to result in improved psychological well-being..