16
allegations of state involvement in the violations, it seems more probable that these officers
mentioned were acting according to a strategy and orders.
Table 12.
Ranks of Officers identified as committing gross human rights violations.
Rank
District Commanding Officer
Officer-in-Charge
Chief Superintendent
Chief Inspector
Inspector
Assistant-Inspector
Detective
Sergeant
Constable
Number
1
6
1
1
12
4
2
14
18
Percentage
1.7
10.2
1.7
1.7
20.3
6.8
3.4
23.7
30.1
10.
The current situation
The militia remain deployed throughout the communities of Zimbabwe, both urban and rural.
Training camps have been increased, and there have increased intakes for all camps. The reports
of militia-driven violence are increasing, but the most sinister development in the current time
frame is the involvement of militia in food related activities. There are now numerous reports of
militia determining who shall have access to food and other scarce commodities. This has been a
feature of all the recent reports of the Food Security Network (FOSENET), an alliance of NGO’s
concerned with the humanitarian crisis. In their January report, FOSENET makes this comment xxix:
Reported political interference in commercial sales has also increased
compared to November reports, with reports of youth militias and police
controlling food queues also making decisions on access or claiming
preferential access for some. The reported control by police of food queues
for commercial supplies appears to have been a response to the tensions
generated by scarcities, but has also brought increased report of political bias
through militias. Political barriers have superseded cost as the major reported
barrier to accessing commercial supplies.
Similar comments were made in the November 2002 report issued by FOSENET, but this report
did not identify militia as primary offenders, rather making the comment that there was political
interference with food access in 38% of the districts surveyedxxx. There are also allegations that
the militia are being given preferential access to food and other scarce commodities, and that
they have hence become deeply involved in black market activities. FOSENET’s most recent report
shows little improvement in the situationxxxi.
This adds a whole new dimension to the already serious problems, and raises the concerns about
possible genocide. Whilst this may seem a little dramatic, it should be borne in mind that
genocide, as defined by the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide, does
include the withholding of access to crucial vectors of support under the definition of genocide.
Amongst the other acts or behaviours that constitute genocide, the Convention includes
“deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to destroy a group ”, and this includes the
deliberate deprivation of resources needed for the group’s physical survival, such as clean water,
food, clothing, shelter or medical services. Here it should also be pointed out that conspiracy to
commit genocide is as punishable under the Convention as actually committing genocide, so it
becomes very important to disentangle ZanuPF merely condoning the militia interfering with food
access from actually encouraging this. Here evidence that the government and ZanuPF are taking
The Perpetrators of Gross Human Rights Violations in the current violence in Zimbabwe.
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents