REDRESS/AMANI
regarding
the full extent of the convicted persons liability can also cause a
difficulty even if the compensation claim is only for pecuniary loss, such as medical
expenses, because the convicted person could argue, for example, that some of the
treatment was not necessary or could have been obtained more cheaply. 166 An
award will not be made unless the injured party or the prosecutor acting on the
injured partys instructions applies for it,167 and the court must ensure that where
appropriate and practicable the injured party is acquainted with the right to apply
for a compensation award.168 If an award is made, the beneficiary can be made to
provide security to repay the compensation in case the conviction is reversed on
appeal or review. 169 An award has the same effect as a civil judgment, giving rise
to the right to proceed with a writ of execution against the convicted person s
property,170 and debarring the injured person from bringing civil proceedings against
the convicted person arising from the same injuries. 171 If an award is not sought, or
is sought but is refused, the injured party is not precluded from seeking a civil
remedy against the convicted person. 172
The second mechanism arises from Section 358 (3) of the Act in terms of which a
criminal court may postpone or suspend all or part of a sentence (except for
murder, conspiracy to murder or any offence where there is a laid down minimum
sentence) on listed specified terms, including the payment of compensation for
damage or pecuniary loss caused by the offence,173 except where an award has
been made for compensation under Part XIX of the Act. 174 This seldom used power
to suspend part of a sentence on condition of payment of compensation was
exercised in the dramatic case of the prosecution, conviction and sentencing of
Zimbabwes ex-President, the Reverend Canaan Sodino Banana 175 in 1998, and
upheld on appeal.176 Banana was convicted in the High Court on two counts of
sodomy and several others involving sexual offences between himself and other
men (only one of the encounters was consensual). He was sentenced to a period of
imprisonment, a portion of which was suspended on condition that he paid a lump
sum as compensation to one of the complainants. He appealed against conviction
and sentence, and the Supreme Court held that the discretion reposing in a trial
court in relation to the conditions on which a sentence may be suspended are very
166
Section 369 gives the courts authority to call further documentary or verbal evidence to determine whether or
not to award compensation, but in practice they are very reluctant to risk converting criminal proceedings into fullblown civil hearings to determine damages, for obvious reasons.
167
Section 368 (1).
168
Section 368 (2).
169
Section 370.
170
Section 372. Section 373 gives the court the right to make the award out of monies taken from the convicted
person on or after his arrest, or produced during the trial, or known to be in his bank account.
171
Section 374.
172
Section 375.
173
Section 358 (3) (b).
174
Section 358 (3) (c) also provides that another specified term is the rendering of some specified benefit or
service to any person injured or aggrieved by the offence, with the proviso that this will only apply if the injured or
aggrieved person has consented thereto.
175
Banana became the countrys first President at independence in 1980, at that time a largely ceremonial post
under the Lancaster House Constitution. Mugabe was the first Prime Minister. In 1987 the Constitution was
amended and Mugabe became the first executive President, the position of Prime Minister being at the same time
abolished : see above footnote 26. Banana retired from active politics on a generous State pension, and died in
2003.
176
The criminal trial is reported at S v Banana 1998 (2) ZLR 533 (H), and the appeal case at S v Banana 2000 (1)
ZLR 607 (S).
35
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents