that promote a system of checks and balances. In that regard, the judiciary must check against the
legislature and the executive to ensure that those branches are exercising their authority appropriately.
Likewise, the executive must do the same with respect to the judiciary. For instance, in South Africa,
Canada and the United States of America, the judiciary has the authority to review the constitutionality
of legislation passed by parliament or regulations made by cabinet ministers; as well as the
constitutionality of the decisions made by the president or the legislature. In the same countries, the
legislature is constitutionally empowered to provide oversight of the executive, demanding
accountability concerning the decisions made by the executive and the judiciary.
Independent, access to adequate resources
Separation of power requires that each of the three branches of government have independent access
to adequate resources. This is meant to avoid a scenario where the branch that controls resources uses
such power to undermine the independence of the other branches. The constitution must therefore
guarantee access to adequate funding by each of the branches
To establish whether and how far the COPAC draft constitution captures and promotes the doctrine of
separation of powers, an analysis is provided in the table below on how each of the above mentioned
basic tenets of the doctrine are provided for in this draft constitution.
Tenet
Where the tenet is captured in Remarks
the COPAC draft
Institutional division of state
governance into the three
branches-executive,
judiciary
and legislature
Observance of the principle of
separation of powers is captured
as a principle of good
governance which binds all
organs of the state at all levels
Recognition of the doctrine of
separation of powers as part of
the founding values gives
adequate and proper weight and
constitutional protection of this
concept.
Section 5.1 (2) reposes This clearly shows the division of
executive authority in the state governance into the three
president and the cabinet branches.
(the executive).
Giving
the
president,
legislative authority (to make
Section 6.2 (1) reposes
primary legislation) may
legislative authority in the
undermine separation of
parliament (consisting of the
powers.
national assembly and the
senate), while section 8.1
gives judiciary authority to
the courts outlined from 8.1
(a-h).
26
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents