20,000 individuals, the community leaders said. For example, at least four secondary
schools and 18 primary schools would be forced to close, and there are no plans to reopen
them elsewhere.140 A ZMDC official supported the view that relocation plans were premature
and without merit, and noted that the ZMDC had not yet done a comprehensive exploration
to determine whether or not relocation might be necessary.141 Some local people believed
that the proposed relocation is a ZANU-PF project designed to punish the people of Marange
for voting overwhelmingly for the opposition MDC in the March 29, 2008 elections.142
Human Rights Watch has established that Zimbabwean authorities have so far failed to
comply with several consultation and compensation requirements. On February 1, 2009, the
then governor of Manicaland, Chris Mushohwe, accompanied by a group of soldiers,
informed the local community gathered at Chiadzwa primary school that relocation of the
community was imminent and that the government would not compensate anyone.143 A
villager who attended the address said Mushohwe informed villagers that Chiadzwa and
Mukwada wards were to be evicted by mid-2009 to make way for mining operations. There
was no consultation about the proposed move.144
The ZMDC has not carried out an environmental impact assessment in Marange. Neither has
the government conducted one in Kondozi farm, the proposed site of relocation. Fear has
muted community opposition. One local leader told Human Rights Watch that because of the
involvement of the military, the leaders in Marange were too scared to openly oppose
relocation or seek legal representation to challenge the proposed evictions.145
The Zimbabwe Environmental Law Association (ZELA) told Human Rights Watch that any
relocation of the local community currently living in and around the diamond fields should
be in strict accordance with domestic environmental law and international standards
regarding relocations and compensation for the displaced.146 Zimbabwe’s Environmental
Management Act, 2002 (Chapter 20:27), obliges the state or relevant private authorities to
“carry out environmental impact assessment[s] before undertaking any mining or relocation
and put in place required management procedures and plans, ensure informed public
140
Human Rights Watch interviews with local councillors B.K. and F.M., Marange, February 22, 2009.
141
Human Rights Watch interview with ZMDC official M.M., Marange, February 21, 2009.
142
Human Rights Watch interview with local community leader, Marange, February 21, 2009.
143
Human Rights Watch interview with local councillor B.K., Marange, February 21, 2009.
144
Human Rights Watch interview with villager R.C., Marange, February 20, 2009.
145
Human Rights Watch interviews with local leaders J.M., D.M., and C.D., Marange, February 22, 2009.
146
Human Rights Watch interview with ZELA officials S.M. and M.M., Harare, February 26, 2009.
45
Human Rights Watch | June 2009
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents