28 | Zimbabwe Rule of Law Journal
is a fair labour practice and standard. Thus, when interpreting the provisions of s65 (1) of the
Constitution of Zimbabwe, there should be inclusion of the right to fair dismissal. In dealing
with cases of fair labour standards as set in the Labour Act the courts will be essentially be
dealing with matters raising constitutional issues. In the case of NEHAWU v University of
Cape Town (NEHAWU) the court ruled that because the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 gave
content to the rights in respect of labour relations in s 23 of the constitution, its interpretation
application “in application compliance with the constitution” are constitutional issues.
The court in NEHAWU further held that the right to fair labour standards and practices in s
23(1) of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 is applicable to both the workers and employers.
Rautenbach argues that the focus of s23 (1) of South African Labour Relations Act is to
ensure that the relationship between the worker and the employer is fair to both.10 He says
the right not to be unfairly dismissed is essential to the right to fair labour practices.11
The Supreme Court of Zimbabwe (SCZ) seems to have adopted an opposite approach in
dealing with matters of unfair dismissal. Its standard is clearly a common law approach as
opposed to ILO jurisprudence yet the common law does not define what unfair dismissal
constitutes. The approach by the Zimbabwean Supreme Court seems to be conservative as
it is based on the concept of lawfulness and not fairness.
There is a difference between the two concepts of fairness and lawfulness. A termination
maybe within the parameters of the law but yet not fair. Lawfulness is confined to what the
rules of law say yet fairness referred to in s12B of the Labour Act (28.01) extends beyond
what the rules of law enunciate. Fairness also includes the aspect of equity and morality
to some extent unlike law that may be law despite its moral content.12 Hence, the correct
10
I M Rautenbach, Overview of Constitutional Court Decisions on the Bill of Rights-2002, TSAR 2003 p182
11
Ibid
12
Lovemore Madhuku, Introduction to Law In Zimbabwe, Harare, Weaver Press, 2010
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents