JUSTICE IN ZIMBABWE
92
____________________________________________________________________
and Luphahla. This was creating the impression among MDC members that they
could commit such crimes and get away with them. The result was that the violence
by MDC members was increasing day by day and it had now reached “alarming
proportions”.
Conclusion
This series of cases illustrates once again the malign effect of politics intruding into
the administration of justice. The deaths of Nkala and Luphahla were almost certainly
politically inspired, but the immediate reaction of the government was that the two
had been killed by members of the opposition MDC, and the government-controlled
news media trumpeted this view to the exclusion of all else. Police investigations
seem to have been directed solely at proving the government’s allegations correct,
without regard to any other line of enquiry. The police seem to have ignored
suggestions made in the independent press, that Cain Nkala may have been killed by
members of his own war veterans’ organisation.145 If, after nine months, the only
evidence the police have managed to get are a couple of confessions whose
admissibility will probably be challenged, then their investigations have certainly not
been very fruitful. If, as seems likely, the suspects who have been indicted are
acquitted for lack of credible evidence, then the true murderers of Nkala and Luphahla
will have escaped justice.
Topic 5
5. THE CHINHOYI FARMERS CASE
Introduction
On 6 August 2001 twenty-one whites, mainly commercial farmers, were arrested in
the Chinhoyi area and charged with public violence. The incident that gave rise to
charges is described succinctly and, as it turned out, accurately by a writer 146:
“The worst outbreak of violence occurred in August 2001 in the Chinhoyi
farming district, sixty miles north-west of Harare. It started after a group of
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents