As can be seen from Table 11, the army are identified as perpetrators acting alone in a high
number of cases, but it is also evident that the police as a whole are the most commonly identified
perpetrators.
Table 11
The police and army identified as perpetrators
Perpetrator
Army
Uniformed Branch
Riot Squad
CID
Support Unit
ZANU(PF)
PISI
CIO
Acting alone
75
84
31
15
14
7
2
0
With others
39
27
23
12
4
0
0
1
Total
114
111
54
27
18
7
2
1
Percentage
39.18
38.14
18.56
9.28
6.19
2.41
0.69
0.34
As indicated above, the cases mounted in the Zimbabwe High Court do corroborate the more
general picture emerging from data in the monthly Political Violence reports of the Human Rights
Forum. There are a few additional aspects that are felt worthy of more detailed analysis, and
these deal with the issues of detention, torture, shootings, the targeting of political opponents of
the government, and the apparently central role of the Zimbabwe Republic Police in perpetrating
human rights violations.
2.4 Associations with political events and issues
As was noted in the earlier analysis of the data from the monthly Political Violence reports, there
is a strong association between human rights violations and political events, especially elections,
but not exclusively so. Hence, this association was examined in respect of the civil litigation cases,
where 132 cases (45%) could be classified as ‘political’ in that the plaintiffs asserted that their rights
were violated because they were members of a political party or a civic group seen to be opposed
to the government (Table 12).
Table 12
Association of frequency of violations with political events
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
Non-political
(n = 159)
25.8%*
1.9%
6.3%
6.3%
12.6%
27.7%
15.1%
2.5%
1.9%
Political
(n = 132)
0
1.5%
0
11.4%
12.1%
59.9%*
10.6%
4.6%
0
*χ2: 1998 (39.62; P = 0.005); 2003 (30.6; P = 0.005)
There were no differences in the years between the two groups, with only 1998 and 2003 showing
significant differences, and 2003 is accounted for mainly by cases from Buhera. There were several
cases of politically motivated arson in Buhera and the police assaulted and tortured the alleged
accused.
13
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents