Membership in voluntary associations is positively related to political
engagement;
Conventional modes of political participation are strongly related to
membership in voluntary associations, and, the less conventional the mode of
political engagement, the smaller the relationship to membership of
voluntary associations;2
There is little evidence for causal relations between membership of voluntary
associations and political participation, with most evidence being only
correlational.
There is still much to be done to fully understand social capital and its relationship to
active citizenship, but this has not dampened enthusiasm for the concept which has
nonetheless received increasing attention. It is not merely in the domain of political or
vertical participation that social capital is seen as important, and much work has also focused
on the community, or horizontal participation. This was an important point made by Putnam
(1993) earlier on. Where vertical relationships dominate (as in Zimbabwe, for instance), civic
initiative is discouraged and social capital is undermined. Horizontal relationships, assumed
to require trust and reciprocity, will generate social capital, and can be seen, for example, in
communities where crime is low and little formal policing is required. Thus, community
becomes a critical feature of social capital. Additionally, politics is not merely a concern with
representation and state institutions, but operates wherever and whenever human beings act in
common enterprise (Leftwich.2009).
An empirical examination of social capital in five Australian communities provides
additional food for thought (Onyx & Bullen.2000). Based on a questionnaire investigation,
with 1,211 subjects, factor analysis revealed eight independent factors – community, agency,
trust, workplace, neighbor, tolerance, friends, and value of life. Each factor was associated
with specific behaviours. For example, agency was associated with took initiative at work,
helped workmate, free to speak out, seeks mediation for dispute, and can find information.
Interestingly, social capital in this study was not associated with demographic variables: age,
gender, work, salary or qualification levels did not correlate with the eight factors. But, there
were several findings in respect of demographics:
Women were less likely to feel safe in their local communities than men;
People with more children were likely to participate more in the local
community than those with fewer children;
The longer one had lived in a community, the more likely there would be
stronger neighborhood connections.
So, at least according to Onyx and Bullen, social capital seems to connote a
communitarian variable and suggests collective goods available to all citizens, van Deth’s
second meaning for social capital (van Deth.2001).
There is one detailed African study on social capital, examining the relationship
between social capital and political violence (Bhavnani & Backer. 2007), which did include
Zimbabwe among the 16 countries studied. In summary, the study showed strong relations
between various factors hypothesized to be associated with social capital: associational
membership, civic engagement, trust, social cohesion and equality. The study found that
membership in professional and business associations was significantly more likely to be
2
Here see also Finkel (1987), and the finding that unconventional participation (aggression) is negatively related to
political efficacy and support for regimes.
6