Sevices Unit (CSU). Contained in the source records4 were the presentation of injuries sustained
through police brutality, types of weapons used by police; victim background details; the nature
of the violation; medical determination of the severity of the injury; the presentation of physical
and mental trauma; site of the injury; and victims’ narratives of the incident in which they were
brutalized by police, detailing what had transpired, why, where and when.
The study population comprised of 19 randomly selected victims of police brutality from a
population of 224 victims that had already been attended to by CSU between July and August
2016. Following a review of the source documents, a semi-structured questionnaire was
administered to the study participants. The semi-structured questionnaire allowed researchers to
capture anticipated response types and capture unpredictable responses that could not be
categorised. Semi-structured questionnaires provide room for probing to get clarifications on
information volunteered by respondents.
The data collection process involved calling potential study participants on mobile numbers they
had provided to CSU, requesting interviews and meeting them at agreed venues, in
consideration for the participants’ safety and anxiety. Study participation was voluntary and
confidentiality was guaranteed.
1.4 Data validation
Information on the names; contact details; medical assessments, therapies prescribed and costs,
as well as legal interventions carried out, was made available from the non-state service
providers for legal, medical and psychosocial assistance. The personnel in these service provider
organisations is experienced and appropriately trained and registered to operate. Information
sourced from the victims was on direct and indirect costs that were not covered by assistance
from service providers. Calculating the costs of political violence to victims is a challenging
task, demanding rigour in the validation process. Data collection for this study involved the
following:
-
medical costs/expenditure provided for and documented by an organisation that provides
medical and psycho-social assistance
-
legal costs/expenditure provided for and documented by an organisation that provides
4
from member organisations of the Forum consortium that provide legal, medical and psychosocial assistance to
victims of organised violence and torture
9