presence in civilian life is unlawful and unconstitutional, never mind their involvement in alleged gross
human rights violations.
This finding, of the involvement of both state and non-state agents in alleged violations, does not
imply that all these separate groups were always present together, but rather that there were
significant combinations on a regular basis. For example, the illustrative case below shows the
interaction between these various groups.
Before the March 29 election, on the 16/03/08, a soldier (NAME PROVIDED) and council
candidate Zanu PF (NAME PROVIDED) came to my house and gave me a strong warning
to stop campaigning for MDC. They took me to Muzarabani Community Hall and beat me
up with metal bars under the feet and on the lower leg. I sustained serious wounds and
was treated at St Alberts. They detained me for two days and released me. They would
give me water no food. The leg is still painful. I did not stop my campaigns and was a
polling agent during the elections. Then the second time, on Sunday 04/05/08, Zanu PF
youths came to my house together with senator (NAME PROVIDED) and Mm (NAME
PROVIDED), they were so many. I sneaked out of the house and disappeared without
them noticing. They knocked on my door and my wife came out. I heard her screaming
and being beaten. I could see from a distance. They told my wife that they are looking
for me and want to kill me this time. I did not have money to leave home as the money
was burnt in the house. On 06/05/08, I went to Muzarabani to look for money and
assistance so I could leave as I was fearing for my life. There I saw Mu (NAME
PROVIDED), a Zanu PF, who told the youths that X is here. The youths came and
apprehended me and then took me to their base. There, I and 8 other MDC supporters
were detained and beaten. I was also detained and beaten under feet, on the buttocks
and in the palms of our hands. During the periods anybody, i.e. Zanu PF, would call us
and beat us. In the morning, everyday around 3am, most of the youths would go and
wait for buses coming from further taking any food on the bus claiming that nothing
should go to Harare because the people there are MDC. They would go with an MDC
youth to help identify the other MDC youths escaping and force them to disembark and
take them to the base to be beaten and detained. Today in the morning as they were
beating us a policeman who I know came and then lied to them and said I have a
pending case with the police and that he wanted to take me. I managed to escape and
got a lift to Harare around 6. My whole body is painful from the beatings. I am worried
about my family at home.
The violations alleged by the victims were not trivial, as can be seen from Table 6.
Table 6
Alleged violations reported
[n=285]
Alleged Violation
Number [%]
Abduction
5[2%]
Assault
78[27%]
Assault [GBH]
210[74%]
Destruction of property
46[16%]
Theft
46[16%]
Unlawful arrest
6[2%]
Unlawful detention
36[13%]
The average number of different violations per person reported was 2.1 [sd.1.3], and a total of 40
[14%] reported being displaced [see Table 7 below]. There are also an appreciable number of
Select target paragraph3
Add to table of contents